TribLIVE

| AandE


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Extraordinarily fine churches can be found all over region

- A view of one of the two 74-foot long stained glass windows at St. Thomas More Church. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
A view of one of the two 74-foot long stained glass windows at St. Thomas More Church. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- A statue of St. Thomas More looks out over the modern, 20th century church named for him in Bethel Park. He was a 16th century martyr, once a trusted counselor to Henry VIII, he was beheaded over his opposition to Henry's break with the Roman church. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
A statue of St. Thomas More looks out over the modern, 20th century church named for him in Bethel Park. He was a 16th century martyr, once a trusted counselor to Henry VIII, he was beheaded over his opposition to Henry's break with the Roman church. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- This view of St. Thomas More Roman Catholic Church in Bethel Park shows a conjuction of elements that create a spiritual space: the dramatic structure, the huge clerestory showering daylight from above, the inspiring two-story-high wood carved image of the risen Christ, and the centrality of the altar, thrust out into the congregation. This was one of the first area churches built in the 1960s after the Second Vatican Council recommended that altars be closer to congregations. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
This view of St. Thomas More Roman Catholic Church in Bethel Park shows a conjuction of elements that create a spiritual space:  the dramatic structure, the huge clerestory showering daylight from above, the inspiring two-story-high wood carved image of the risen Christ, and the centrality of the altar, thrust out into the congregation.  This was one of the first area churches built in the 1960s after the Second Vatican Council recommended that altars be closer to congregations.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- This view of St. Thomas More Roman Catholic Church in Bethel Park shows a conjuction of elements that create a spiritual space: the dramatic structure, the huge clerestory showering daylight from above, the inspiring two-story-high wood-carved image of the risen Christ, and the centrality of the altar, thrust out into the congregation. This was one of the first area churches built in the 1960s after the Second Vatican Council recommended that altars be closer to congregations. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
This view of St. Thomas More Roman Catholic Church in Bethel Park shows a conjuction of elements that create a spiritual space:  the dramatic structure, the huge clerestory showering daylight from above, the inspiring two-story-high wood-carved image of the risen Christ, and the centrality of the altar, thrust out into the congregation.  This was one of the first area churches built in the 1960s after the Second Vatican Council recommended that altars be closer to congregations.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- St. Thomas More Church in Bethel Park is a familiar sight to shoppers at South Hills Village mall. The outside, though, gives scant hint of the structural drama and richness of the interior. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
St. Thomas More Church in Bethel Park is a familiar sight to shoppers at South Hills Village mall.  The outside, though, gives scant hint of the structural drama and richness of the interior.   John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- The entire ceiling of St. Bernard's is painted with various designs. These scenes, painted by muralist Jan Henryk De Rosen, are almost 80 feet above the floor on the ceiling under the church's bell tower. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
The entire ceiling of St. Bernard's is painted with various designs.  These scenes, painted by muralist Jan Henryk De Rosen, are almost 80 feet above the floor on the ceiling under the church's bell tower.   John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- The reredos -- or screen behind the altar, is heavy with gilt and detail at St. Bernard's. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
The reredos -- or screen behind the altar, is heavy with gilt and detail at St. Bernard's.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- This view of the altar, reredos (the screen behind the altar), and the apse of the church show just how intensively decorated the church. The murals in the apse, and the others in the church, were painted by Jan Henryk De Rosen, who also painted the murals for the pope's private chapel at Castel Gondolfo, the papal summer retreat in Italy. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
This view of the altar, reredos (the screen behind the altar), and the apse of the church show just how intensively decorated the church. The murals in the apse, and the others in the church, were painted by Jan Henryk De Rosen, who also painted the murals for the pope's private chapel at Castel Gondolfo, the papal summer retreat in Italy.    John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- St. Bernard's creates a spiritual space not just with awesome scale, but with intensive decoration throughout. A line of hanging lights are suspended at a relatively low height over the pews, which helps create a more comfortable space without denying the interior height of the church. The lights proceed almost as if in procession towards the altar, and then rise up as the reach it. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
St. Bernard's creates a spiritual space not just with awesome scale, but with intensive decoration throughout.  A line of hanging lights are suspended at a relatively low height over the pews, which helps create a more comfortable space without denying the interior height of the church. The lights  proceed almost as if in procession towards the altar, and then rise up as the reach it.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux. The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux.  The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby  Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux. The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux.  The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby  Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
John Conti | for the Tribune-Review - First Church of Christ, Scientist, built in the 1930s, was designed by a Chicago architect who specialized in Christian Science churches and designed 140 of them across the country.
<div style='float:right;width:100%;' align='right'><em> John Conti  |  for the Tribune-Review</em></div>First Church of Christ, Scientist, built in the 1930s, was designed by a Chicago architect who specialized in Christian Science churches and designed 140 of them across the country.
- The 'Colonial' style in churches -- following English precedent set by such famous architects as Christopher Wren and James Gibbs -- always featured bright interiors with clear glass windows. In the 17th and 18th century in England this was intended to facilitate the reading of scripture and prayers by the congregation during services. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
The 'Colonial' style in churches -- following English precedent set by such famous architects as Christopher Wren and James Gibbs -- always featured bright interiors with clear glass windows.  In the 17th and 18th century in England this was intended to facilitate the reading of scripture and prayers by the congregation during services.   John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- At Mt. Lebanon's Christian Science Church, built in the 1930s, the glass in the windows is sightly frosted to appear antique John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
At Mt. Lebanon's Christian Science Church, built in the 1930s, the glass in the windows is sightly frosted to appear antique  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- The interior of the Christian Science Church is bright and serene. The simplicity of the Colonial style originally developed from a concern to have churches that emphasized scripture rather than ritual. In the Christian Science tradition the central feature of a service is two readers who share the double pulpit -- called the 'desk' -- to read from scripture and from the writings of Mary Baker Eddy, the church's founder. There is no altar and only the desk and seating are on the platform at the front of the church. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
The interior of the Christian Science Church is bright and serene.  The simplicity of the Colonial style originally developed from a concern to have churches that emphasized scripture rather than ritual.  In the Christian Science tradition the central feature of a service is two readers who share the double pulpit -- called the 'desk' -- to read from scripture and from the writings of Mary Baker Eddy, the church's founder.  There is no altar and only the desk and seating are on the platform at the front of the church.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- The interior of the Christian Science Church is bright and serene. The simplicity of the Colonial style originally developed from a concern to have churches that emphasized scripture rather than ritual. In the Christian Science tradition the central feature of a service is two readers who share the double pulpit -- called the 'desk' -- to read from scripture and from the writings of Mary Baker Eddy, the church's founder. There is no altar and only the desk and seating are on the platform at the front of the church. John Conti / for the Tribune-Review
The interior of the Christian Science Church is bright and serene.  The simplicity of the Colonial style originally developed from a concern to have churches that emphasized scripture rather than ritual.  In the Christian Science tradition the central feature of a service is two readers who share the double pulpit -- called the 'desk' -- to read from scripture and from the writings of Mary Baker Eddy, the church's founder.  There is no altar and only the desk and seating are on the platform at the front of the church.  John Conti / for the Tribune-Review
- Exterior view of the Mt. Lebanon United Lutheran Church on Washington Road. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
Exterior view of the Mt. Lebanon United Lutheran Church on Washington Road.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- The Mt. Lebanon Lutheran Church successfully combines traditional elements with modern architecture. A new organ, built in Italy, was installed in 2002. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
The Mt. Lebanon Lutheran Church successfully combines traditional elements with modern architecture.  A new organ, built in Italy, was installed in 2002.  John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- At Mt. Lebanon Lutheran Church an unusual arrangement in which the communion rail surrounds the altar creates a strong feeling of togetherness when congregants gather facing each other for the sacrament. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
At Mt. Lebanon Lutheran Church an unusual arrangement in which the communion rail surrounds the altar creates a strong feeling of togetherness when congregants gather facing each other for the sacrament. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
- Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux. The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well. John Conti / For the Tribune-Review
Mt. Lebanon's St. Bernard Church is a Romanesque-style church with some Gothic details, and is intended to look on the outside like the 12th century abbeys built in Southeastern France by its namesake, St. Bernard of Clairvaux.  The designer was William Perry, an architect who made his home in nearby  Dormont but designed churches in many cities other than Pittsburgh as well.   John Conti / For the Tribune-Review

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.

Daily Photo Galleries

Saturday, Dec. 22, 2012, 8:56 p.m.
 

Pittsburgh has always been a city of fine churches.

We are unusual in having four in our region designed by Ralph Adams Cram of Boston, probably the most famous church architect of the 20th century. These are his Gothic-inspired East Liberty Presbyterian Church — which Cram considered his masterpiece; Calvary Episcopal Church in Shadyside; Holy Rosary Church in Homewood; and First Presbyterian Church in Greensburg.

Local architects have contributed many equally distinguished church buildings, too. Sacred Heart Church, by Pittsburgher Carlton Strong, with one of the longest and highest naves in town, sits quite comfortably across from Calvary Episcopal in a setting that is a little like a village green.

And the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission will soon erect one of its roadside historical markers in front of St. Agnes Center at Carlow University to commemorate John T. Comes, a Pittsburgh architect who designed dozens of major churches here and across the country in the early 1900s. It's believed to be only the second state historical marker honoring an individual architect.

These churches — and others — are justly famous, but there are extraordinarily fine churches in almost every neighborhood in our region.

So, with Christmas upon us, let's take a look today at four area churches, considering how the buildings shape feelings during worship — how they create spaces that are spiritual.

The four I've chosen are within three miles of each other on or near a stretch of Washington Road (Route 19), south of the city in Mt. Lebanon and Bethel Park.

Perhaps the best-known is St. Bernard Roman Catholic Church in Mt. Lebanon, which some call “the cathedral of the South Hills.” It is one of three big churches clustered on one of that town's highest hills, and it was designed by William Perry of Dormont, who succeeded John Comes after he died.

It is spellbinding from the outside — an immense Romanesque mix of brown and red-brown stone, a multicolored tile roof and a massive bell tower. Inside, it illustrates well the humbling feeling — the awe — that you feel in large cathedrals everywhere. The scale is enormous. You can't take all of it in at once, and that's part of its effect and appeal.

As in all cathedral-like churches, there is a long nave and a high roof with imposing stone arches overhead. The central aisle leads to a large high altar eight steps up from the floor. As you walk down the aisle, you find yourself under the bell tower, where the interior ceiling is almost 80-feet high.

St. Bernard's is elaborately decorated — full of sculptures, mosaics, murals, stained glass and symbolism. The murals are by Jan Henryk De Rosen — who similarly painted murals at the National Cathedral in Washington and for the pope's private chapel in his summer residence at Castel Gondolfo in Italy.

The lavishness of the artwork, and the textures of the stone and rich marble throughout, create a setting for ritual and liturgy.

You won't find any of that, though, when you go down the street to Mt. Lebanon's First Church of Christ, Scientist. Here, the church has little in the way of decoration. Its much-smaller interior is restrained, intimate and serene. There is no altar at all, but rather a platform simply furnished with chairs and a large double-pulpit at the center front from which two readers conduct most of a service.

This is a Colonial-style church, and its simplicity is intended to emphasize the reading of scripture, rather that ritual or liturgy. Its windows are plain glass — slightly frosted to look antique — and the interior always has a feeling of bright openness.

Charles Draper Faulkner, a Chicago architect, designed this and some 140 other Christian Science churches around the country.

Both St. Bernard's and the Christian Science church are traditional, albeit in different ways. But churches in modern styles can be spiritual, too.

St. Thomas More Roman Catholic Church on Fort Couch Road in Bethel Park (just off Route 19, across from South Hills Village mall) was among the first to be built in the 1960s after the Second Vatican Council. The council promoted bringing the altar and priests closer to the congregation.

As a result, this uncompromisingly modern church is octagonal in shape with the altar in the middle, thrust forward on a low platform only two steps high. Congregants practically surround it on three sides. Though it's a large church, nobody sits more than 14 rows away from the altar, giving a large congregation a strong sense of being a spiritual community.

The church is dramatic in structure with a central clerestory that washes the sanctuary with daylight. A two-story-high woodcut behind the altar shows an image of the risen Christ that gives the church an overall feeling of optimism.

A sense of community also is emphasized at the modernist Mt. Lebanon United Lutheran Church on Washington Road — but in a special way rarely seen elsewhere. The sacrament of communion is central to Lutheran worship, and, here, the communion rail is on all four sides of the altar, contributing to a strong feeling of togetherness as congregants gather facing each other for the sacrament.

Spirituality, of course, depends on the people, as any pastor will tell you. But churches have been designed with spaces that facilitate that spirituality for thousands of years — sometimes with great simplicity, sometimes with elaborate decoration or soaring structures — but always with feeling in mind.

John Conti is a former news reporter who has written extensively over the years about architecture, planning and historic-preservation issues.

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.

 

 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Architecture

  1. Change buildings, but don’t shortchange them