TribLIVE

| AandE


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Lehrer's JFK novel 'Top Down' lacks impact

‘Top Down: A Novel of the Kennedy Assassination'

Author: Jim Lehrer

Publisher: Random House, $26, 208 pages

By Douglass K. Daniel
Saturday, Oct. 19, 2013, 6:23 p.m.
 

“What if?” is a tried-and-true starting point for a novelist. In the case of “Top Down,” PBS newsman and veteran fiction writer Jim Lehrer asks an intriguing question, but doesn't quite come up with an equally intriguing answer.

What if the Secret Service agent who decided not to equip the presidential limousine with its bubble top ended up blaming himself for John F. Kennedy's assassination? Lehrer comes to the question naturally because, on Nov. 22, 1963, he was a young Dallas newspaper reporter covering the president's visit. In fact, he asked about the Plexiglas covering as the security detail prepared for the day's events.

In Lehrer's 21st novel, Dallas newspaper reporter Jack Gilmore looks back at the events of that awful day from the standpoint of five years. It's 1968, and college student Marti Walters enlists Gilmore to help save her father from the depression that's killing him. He's been tortured by the belief that the Plexiglas covering he decided not to install would have deflected Lee Harvey Oswald's bullets.

Gilmore is moved less by the idea of saving agent Walters from himself — or by the possibility of romance with Marti — than the prospect of a sweet exclusive for the newspaper. He agrees to keep the whole episode off the record in order to participate, but can he keep such a promise?

It's a promising plot, especially as a cultural take on the event that rocked the country a half-century ago. Yet, Lehrer is slow to get it off the ground — recording the Walters family's reaction to the assassination is not at all compelling — and the payoff is thin. A bigger point about America then and now, how we deal with honor, or even the “what if's” in our own lives is too understated if not absent.

Two years ago, Stephen King turned his own “what if” on the Kennedy assassination into a doorstop of a best-seller, “1 122/63.” Under 200 pages, Lehrer's novel is a quarter the size of King's — and far lighter in all the ways that count.

Douglass K. Daniel, author of “Tough as Nails: The Life and Films of Richard Brooks,” is a contributing writer for the Associated Press

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.

 

 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. With Malkin out, Penguins fall to Flyers, 4-1
  2. Steelers re-sign DE Geathers
  3. Shouf’s Cafe can fill your belly with Mediterranean cuisine and comfort food
  4. Authorities release name of Greensburg man who jumped off overpass onto Route 30
  5. Fear of being grounded keeps some pilots from revealing mental issues
  6. Hospital union rallies continue in East Franklin, Kittanning
  7. Teacher from Mt. Lebanon kept home, made repairs around house
  8. ‘Birth tourism’ business booming in China
  9. Wines claimed to be toxic with arsenic won’t be pulled by state Liquor Control Board
  10. Time catches up with longstanding Port Vue group
  11. Jeannette teen ordered to stand trial in classmate’s slaying