TribLIVE

| AandE


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

'Only God Forgives' a movie that's this 1-note

‘Only God Forgives'

¬

R

Manor Theatre

By Ann Hornady
Thursday, July 18, 2013, 8:55 p.m.
 

You've got to hand it to Nicolas Winding Refn. Only a filmmaker of his supreme self-confidence is willing to put one of the most charismatic stars on the planet in his movie, only to reduce his leading man's face to an unrecognizable mess by the film's end.

The swollen, bloodied features in question belong to Ryan Gosling, who in “Only God Forgives” hands out and receives beatings with such metronomic regularity that they feel like the big dance numbers in bad musicals: showy, artificial and meaningless. In some ways, “Only God Forgives” qualifies as a follow-up to Refn's 2011 film “Drive,” which starred Gosling in a similarly terse, somber performance.

But where that film cleverly addressed its own pulp-crime genre and the artifice of Hollywood, here Refn advances nothing but his own obsessions, which quickly grow tiresome. He has often proudly declared himself to be a “fetish filmmaker,” interested in making movies purely on the basis of what attracts him; the audience, for its part, doesn't figure.

Presumably, “Only God Forgives” will manage to find its share of dedicated viewers — in this case, people turned on by lurid, neon-colored nightscapes, Asian martial arts, graphic brutality, body horror and the perverse thrill of hearing English rose Kristin Scott Thomas deliver arias of vulgar verbal abuse. Here she plays Crystal, a blonde-haired cougar who has arrived in Bangkok to avenge the death of her favorite son by way of her least-favorite son, Julian (Gosling).

Cruel, immoral, racist and just a little bit incest-y, Crystal is a monstrous mother who make Euripides look like Louisa May Alcott. This is a woman who, when she hears that one of her offspring raped and killed a 16-year-old girl, says, “I'm sure he had his reasons.”

But once the initial jolt has worn off, Crystal isn't nearly as interesting as, say, Jacki Weaver's character in “Animal Kingdom,” a criminal den-mother of fascinating contradictions.

Instead, Refn is content to let Scott Thomas simply be ugly — inside and out — while Gosling smolders soulfully, clenches his fists laconically, and otherwise sleepwalks through a modern-day Bangkok filmed to resemble one of hell's more-tawdry outer circles.

Slow, methodical and mannered, “Only God Forgives” suggests that Refn — whose impressive earlier outings include the similarly violent “Valhalla Rising” and “Bronson” — has hit a nihilistic dead end. Rather than bold and subversive, his fetishism feels hermetic, claustrophobic and exhausted. The most objectionable thing about “Only God Forgives” isn't that it's shocking or immoral, but that it's so finally, fatally dull.

Ann Hornaday is a staff writer for the Washington Post.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Movies

  1. Small Pittsburgh theaters are big hits with movie-theme parties
  2. Review: ‘As Above’ so-so
  3. Review: ‘Land Ho!’ makes for mild-mannered ‘one last hurrah’ buddy pic
  4. Brothers overcome challenges to film ‘As Above/So Below’ in catacombs
  5. DVD reviews: ‘The Normal Heart,’ ‘Blended’ and ‘Belle’
  6. McCandless Cinemark set to open Sept. 19
  7. Actor-director Richard Attenborough dies at 90
  8. Pittsburgh-shot ‘The Last Witch Hunter’ seeks extras
  9. ‘Sin City’: Rodriguez, Miller talk noir, not society
  10. Jolie and Pitt officially tie the knot
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.