U.S. airlines in no rush to add cellphone calls
By The Los Angeles Times
Published: Wednesday, October 3, 2012, 5:58 p.m.
Updated: Thursday, January 31, 2013
LOS ANGELES — In the skies over Europe, Asia and the Middle East, airline passengers can chat and text on cellphones without getting an angry look from a flight attendant.
Thai Airways, with regular flights from Los Angeles to Bangkok, recently announced plans to offer onboard cellphone service, joining about 20 other foreign-based carriers that already offer it.
But U.S. carriers are not rushing to jump on the bandwagon, even though aviation experts say new satellite-based technology makes airborne cellphone calls safe.
“It's not a priority of ours right now,” said Mary Frances Fagan, a spokeswoman for American Airlines.
The Federal Aviation Administration and the Federal Communications Commission prohibit cellphone calls on planes over U.S. airspace, but federal officials say they would listen to requests by airlines to lift the restrictions.
But don't expect airline officials in the United States to press for such changes. They cite the extra cost and hassle to test, install and operate cellphone technology as one reason to keep cellphones off domestic flights.
And airlines point out that passengers are not clamoring for the service, according to several surveys that say most air travelers expect that in-flight cellular service will lead to loud phone conversations and onboard fury.
“Cellphone offerings and voice-over data is not something that our members are seeing strong demand for from their passengers,” said Victoria Day, a spokeswoman for Airlines for America, the trade group for the nation's airline industry.
Even flight attendants have voiced opposition, saying cellphone calls would only make their jobs more difficult.
But on foreign airlines, reports of cellphone calls causing disputes or disturbances have been rare, primarily because calls are costly — starting at about $1.20 per minute — and noisy aircraft cabins deter long conversations, according to foreign carriers and their passengers.
On a Virgin Atlantic flight this summer from London to Miami, record producer Corey Johnson's short cellphone call was met with curiosity, not anger, from fellow passengers.
“For a business owner like myself, it's an option that's great to have,” he said, “if, like myself, you never shut off.”
Brett King, an author and speaker on the banking industry who has flown on Emirates Airline and Qatar Airways, said calls cause no friction because passengers are instructed to keep their phones on silent mode to stifle the ring and calls are not allowed in a “quiet zone” of the plane where passengers might be sleeping.
The fear that cellphones on planes will lead to loud conversations and conflicts, King said, are unfounded.
Passengers on Emirates Airline flights have used their cellphones more than 10 million times to send and receive text messages and emails and an additional 625,000 times for voice conversations since the airline began offering the service in 2008, according to the airline. But the airline says it has received only two passenger complaints about loud calls.
“The majority of people are considerate about using cellphones,” said Patrick Brannelly, a spokesman for Emirates, adding that most passengers use their cellphones to send text messages. “It's a self-managing environment in many ways.”
Helping to keep the peace, onboard cell technology typically limits the number of phone calls that can be made simultaneously.
“We found that people are courteous and most calls are shorter than two minutes,” said Ian Dawkins, chief executive of OnAir of Geneva. It is one of two major technology companies that has installed cellphone service on 20 foreign airlines.
But in the United States, passengers and airline officials predict feuds and clashes among fliers if cellphone service is activated on planes.
“If you let people use phones on planes, I'm afraid they will abuse it,” said Meredith Wilson, a Seattle resident who recently flew into Bob Hope Airport in Burbank, Calif. “It could cause a lot of problems.”
Craig Patton, a Denver resident who recently flew to Southern California, said he doesn't mind the ban on cellphone calls on planes.
“I'm not addicted to my cellphone,” he said. “I can go two or three hours without texting or talking on the phone. I'm old school.”
Without demand from passengers, U.S. airline representatives say they won't press federal officials to allow cellphone calls on domestic flights.
“Right now, our focus is on what customers say they want, and that is in-flight Wi-Fi,” said Brad Hawkins, a spokesman for Southwest Airlines, the nation's most popular domestic carrier.
- Westinghouse hires regional president
- Profit drops 29 percent in first quarter at American Eagle Outfitters
- Be a pest employers admire
- Retired UPMC surgeon sues surgical device maker over patents
- Business incubator AlphaLab shows off fledgling Western Pennsylvania firms
- UPMC will cut 100 transcribers’ jobs
- Union members picket at FirstEnergy meeting in W.Va.
- You matter more than your school
- ESPN cutting workforce, ‘smartly managing costs’
- As yen falls, so does cost of products from Japan
- Retailers highlight convenience, service to fight ‘showrooming’
You must be signed in to add comments
To comment, click the Sign in or sign up at the very top of this page.
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.