TribLIVE

| Business


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Judge approves FTC's $22.5M fine of Google for alleged privacy breach

About The Tribune-Review
The Tribune-Review can be reached via e-mail or at 412-321-6460.
Contact Us | Video | Photo Reprints

By The Associated Press

Published: Saturday, Nov. 17, 2012, 12:01 a.m.

SAN FRANCISCO — A federal judge has approved a $22.5 million fine to penalize Google for an alleged privacy breach, rejecting a consumer rights group's plea for tougher punishment.

The blessing from U.S. District Judge Susan Illston was given late Friday. She made her ruling a few hours after a hearing in San Francisco on final arguments about a fine that's the cornerstone of a settlement reached three months ago between the Federal Trade Commission and Google Inc.

The rebuke revolves around allegations that Google duped millions of web surfers using the Safari browser into believing their online activities could not be tracked by the company as long as they didn't change the browser's privacy settings.

That assurance was posted on Google's website this year, even as the Internet search leader was inserting computer coding that bypassed Safari's automatic settings and enabled the company to peer into the online lives of the browser's users.

The FTC concluded that the contradiction between Google's stealth tracking and its privacy assurances to Safari users violated a vow the company made in another settlement with the agency last year. Google had promised not to mislead people about its privacy practices.

While the FTC hailed its actions as proof of its resolve to protect the public interest, a consumer rights group attacked the settlement as an example of ineffectual regulation.

The group, Consumer Watchdog, is trying to bring more attention to the issue as the FTC wraps up a separate investigation into complaints that Google has been stifling competition and raising online ad prices by highlighting its own services in its influential search engine.

Illston, though, found that the fine and other facets of the settlement were all “fair, adequate and reasonable.”

“We're glad the court agreed there was no merit to this challenge,” Google said in a statement.

Consumer Watchdog attorney Gary Reback said he hopes to pressure the FTC to take Google to court in the antitrust investigation, instead of negotiating consent decrees and other types of settlements, as it did in the Safari privacy flap.

A consent decree “is not a good way to police Google,” Reback said after Friday's court hearing.

Reback also is representing some of the Internet companies that have filed complaints against Google in the antitrust case.

FTC Chairman Jon Leibowitz has said he expects regulators to decide whether to sue, settle or simply close the antitrust investigation by the end of this year.

In the Safari case, Consumer Watchdog argued that the fine amounts to loose change for a company like Google, which generates about $22.5 million in revenue every four hours. In legal briefs, Reback asserted that Google should be fined at least $3 billion because of the number of people potentially affected.

The agency said the impact of Google's breach was relatively small, estimating the company picked up about $4 million in revenue from the intrusion.

The FTC considers the fine to be a milestone because it's the largest the agency has ever levied for a civil violation.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Business Headlines

  1. PNC posts 7 percent rise in 1Q profit
  2. Heinz offers Pittsburgh workers a buyout if they are unhappy
  3. Programs help to nudge unemployment among veterans downward
  4. Koppers to acquire 2 Buffalo-based Osmose units for $460M
  5. Recall puts GM sales under microscope
  6. BNY Mellon shareholders vote against splitting CEO and chairman jobs
  7. Robinson bakehouse invests time, love in artisan products
  8. Chinese pork firm plans IPO to raise  as much as $5.3B
  9. Google buys drone maker Titan Aerospace to spread Internet
  10. Fed chair might push for stronger regulations
  11. Consumer price index up 0.2 percent in March
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.