| Business

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Pittsburghers fall short on subsidy bucks under health care law

Email Newsletters

Sign up for one of our email newsletters.

On the Grid

From the shale fields to the cooling towers, Trib Total Media covers the energy industry in Western Pennsylvania and beyond. For the latest news and views on gas, coal, electricity and more, check out On the Grid today.

Friday, Oct. 25, 2013, 10:45 p.m.

There's a downside to fierce health competition in Pittsburgh that makes premiums for Obamacare coverage the lowest in the state: Philadelphians could get a better deal.

A quirk in calculating subsidies will give Philadelphia residents a bigger discount, allowing them to buy coverage for less money than uninsured Pittsburghers.

High premiums mean bigger tax credits under the Affordable Care Act. The result is lower subsidized costs for people buying coverage on outside of Western Pennsylvania — where the state's largest health insurer, Highmark Inc., lowered premiums while battling with UPMC Health Plan.

“Philadelphia has the higher prices, but they will have better subsidies,” said Titus North, executive director of Squirrel Hill consumer advocacy group Citizen Power.

Depending on a person's age and income level, buying a health plan in Pittsburgh could cost more than three times as much as doing so in Philadelphia, the Tribune-Review found in reviewing Obamacare premiums and subsidies.

The law awards discounts through upfront tax credits, primarily to people who don't get coverage from employers, on a sliding scale based on income and the price of a benchmark plan in each market.

Whether intentional or not, Highmark set the benchmark with Community Blue, a plan that excludes UPMC, the region's largest network of hospitals and doctors and Highmark's bitter competitor since the insurer bought West Penn Allegheny Health System in April.

The formula has a big impact on the costs consumers will pay.

A hypothetical 27-year-old making $18,000 a year will pay an annual premium of $1,428 for the lowest-cost plan in Pittsburgh, which is about 40 percent lower than the cheapest premium in Philadelphia. But after applying tax credits, that Pittsburgh plan would cost the person $534 a year — more than three times the $162 after-credit cost on the eastern side of the state.

Chalk it up to another case of Philly trumping the Burgh in government operations?

Highmark defended its pricing and questioned the usefulness of comparing plans in the cities. Each market is unique, with different insurers offering a range of plans, spokeswoman Kristin Ash said.

“It's not that we were intentionally trying to do that,” Ash said.

The benchmark plan in each market is the silver plan, second-lowest in price. Plans range from bronze to silver, then gold and platinum. Highmark sells one Community Blue plan each in bronze and gold levels, but two plans in the silver level.

“Those plans were submitted back when we had no idea what other insurers were going to do,” she said. “Our rate was what we thought the plans would cost.”

But many Pittsburghers will opt for a less-costly Community Blue plan, North predicted.

“They're very unlikely to be able to pay the extra premium to get anything other than Highmark's Community Blue, so they won't have access to UPMC's facilities,” North said.

At the top end of silver plans for sale in Pittsburgh are those from UPMC Health Plan, which cost 70 to 104 percent more than the benchmark. In Philadelphia, the most expensive silver plan is 39 percent more costly than the benchmark.

“Consumers need to be fully informed, as there are trade-offs to be made between price and the access to the providers they want,” UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said.

Alex Nixon is a Trib Total Media staff writer. Reach him at 412-320-7928 or

Add Alex Nixon to your Google+ circles.

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Business Headlines

  1. Black Friday chaos dwindles thanks to earlier deals, online sales
  2. Employers cut back on holiday office parties
  3. Small stores take big gamble by not upgrading credit card readers
  4. Nimble Regal ready for winter with all-wheel drive
  5. Key gets stuck in ignition
  6. Stocks close quiet week with little change
  7. Convinced Fed will raise rates in December, investors parse meaning of ‘gradual’ increase
  8. Fuel cell standoff slows car technology’s rise in popularity
  9. Stop neighbors from stealing your Internet
  10. $170.4M AmEx charge yields whopping perk for Chinese billionaire
  11. GOP Senators Rubio, Cruz at odds on tougher surveillance law