Exclusive interview: Highmark's ousted CEO reflects on fall
On the night of March 25, his face bloodied and right eye swollen shut, Dr. Ken Melani rode more than 60 miles to a friend's house at Nemacolin Woodlands.
Then CEO of Highmark Inc., the state's largest health insurer, he had been in a confrontation with an Oakmont man. Melani's face was so beat up, he did not want to be seen in public.
Melani, 58, stayed in seclusion for two weeks, nursing the wounds with ice bags and warm compressions. A married father of four and arguably one of Pittsburgh's most influential business leaders, he also needed time to deal with the emotional toll of watching his decades-long career and personal life suddenly derail.
"I was hurt," Melani told the Tribune-Review on Thursday, in his first public comments since Highmark fired him April 1, one week after the fight with his girlfriend's husband.
"I did a lot of crying. The personal destruction is something I can't even begin to explain to people. It was devastating," he said.
"I was dropped like a hot potato by everybody in Pittsburgh. As each day passed, I realized that the magnitude of what happened was catastrophic."
During a candid, two-hour conversation in a Pine restaurant, an often emotional Melani described how the incident shook his family, how he feels ostracized from the community and Highmark and how he is trying to rebuild his personal life and reputation. He delivered harsh but heartfelt words toward Highmark's board of directors for making a quick decision without having all the facts.
"I was treated like I had a communicable disease, like I was infecting the organization," Melani said, raising his arms in the air. "What hurts the most is that the company dropped me so fast."
Highmark board Chairman Bob Baum did not return calls for comment. Spokesman Michael Weinstein could not be reached.
The company has said Melani was fired because he repeatedly lied to senior management about his relationship with Melissa Myler, 28, a Highmark business analyst who specializes in sports marketing. Most recently, Myler helped put together a four-year contract for Highmark to sponsor Professional Golfers' Association of America tour events.
"The injuries resulting from Dr. Melani's gross and willful misconduct include injuries to the Blue Cross Blue Shield brand, the company's reputation, risk to business partners and financial harm," according to a Highmark statement announcing his removal.
Melani, who was paid $4.35 million last year, declined to speak about the status of his relationship with Myler or the status of his pension or severance package. One of his attorneys, Sam Cordes, told the Trib that litigation against the insurer remains a possibility.
'Performance speaks for itself'
Melani said he is in discussions with other employers -- some in Pittsburgh, some outside -- about other opportunities. He arrived for the interview alone in a white Cadillac, wearing jeans, a striped shirt and black loafers. His voice turned passionate at times, especially when he talked about his career and his accomplishments.
"Look at the performance of Highmark," Melani said, giving credit to former leaders such as John Brouse. He said his management skills helped the insurer to flourish and achieve national recognition. "My performance speaks for itself," he said.
Melani said he is particularly proud of helping establish Highmark Healthy High 5, a $100 million initiative to improve children's health, and the Highmark Caring Foundation, which helps children and their families who are grieving the death of someone close.
But Melani's reputation was tarnished March 25 in what became one of the most talked-about stories in town. Oakmont police said Melani showed up at Myler's home and walked inside. After Melani ignored requests to leave, the police report said, Myler's husband, Mark, led Melani to the front porch, where a fistfight ensued.
When police arrived, Melani made it clear he was in love with Myler. "(Melani) asked me in an emotional voice if I had ever had a relationship that was everything to me," an Oakmont police officer wrote in a report.
The police report said Melani and Myler began having an affair three weeks after she was hired at Highmark in October. Melani had met the Mylers at several golfing events. Melissa Myler had worked as operations director for the Mylan Classic golf event.
When asked about his relationship with his wife, Melani declined to comment. Attorney Robert Del Greco Jr. told the Trib in a story published yesterday that Melani and Myler continue to have a relationship that he described as "complicated." Myler remains employed at Highmark.
Prosecutors this week dropped simple assault and defiant trespassing charges against Melani after he completed 16 anger management classes. Melani was contrite and said his hurt was compounded by the ordeal's impact on the lives of so many relatives, friends and colleagues.
"What really bothers me the most is that so many people have suffered through this process," he said. "I feel for them."
Melani choked back tears when he spoke about the impact on his parents, who are 85 and 88 and live in Cheswick, where he grew up.
One of the hardest parts of the ordeal was facing his children. Melani has two grown daughters -- ages 33 and 31 -- from a previous marriage. He and his wife, Tracy, have two other daughters, ages 11 and 2 1⁄2.
His voice trembled and tears welled in his eyes when he said his oldest daughters called him while he was staying at Nemacolin.
"We love you, Dad," he said they told him.
Melani said his personal life never affected his business decisions at Highmark, a company that generated $14.8 billion in revenue last year and employs more than 19,000 people.
"Everything I did was in the best interest of Highmark, with a business and community perspective in mind," he said.
Melani said his dismissal has not diminished his affection toward the health insurer, even though officials never allowed him to get his personal belongings from his office on the 31st floor of Fifth Avenue Place, Downtown. They were later delivered to him.
"I have Blues in my blood," he said in reference to the Blue Cross Blue Shield association to which Highmark belongs.
Melani, who orchestrated Highmark's ongoing acquisition of West Penn Allegheny Health System, declined to discuss the future of the deal, which is awaiting approval from state regulators.
Melani would say only that he knows Dr. William Winkenwerder Jr., Highmark's newly appointed CEO who previously worked at the Department of Defense and Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts and owned his own health care consulting firm.
Melani emphasized that he has been fortunate to have the support of family and friends, even though sometimes he feels like some people in public recognize him but are afraid to approach him.
He expressed gratitude to many business and community leaders who have reached out to him, including Murry Gerber, former head of EQT Corp., Giant Eagle CEO David Shapira and city sports figures Mario Lemieux, Ben Roethlisberger and Merril Hoge.
Melani had dinner Wednesday night with Steelers Hall of Fame running back Franco Harris.
"I'm not above being human because I'm Ken Melani," he said. "I've learned to be a better person. Does it mean I'll never make a mistake in my life again? Probably not. I mean, I'm human."
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
You are solely responsible for your comments and by using TribLive.com you agree to our Terms of Service.
We moderate comments. Our goal is to provide substantive commentary for a general readership. By screening submissions, we provide a space where readers can share intelligent and informed commentary that enhances the quality of our news and information.
While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderating decisions are subjective. We will make them as carefully and consistently as we can. Because of the volume of reader comments, we cannot review individual moderation decisions with readers.
We value thoughtful comments representing a range of views that make their point quickly and politely. We make an effort to protect discussions from repeated comments either by the same reader or different readers.
We follow the same standards for taste as the daily newspaper. A few things we won't tolerate: personal attacks, obscenity, vulgarity, profanity (including expletives and letters followed by dashes), commercial promotion, impersonations, incoherence, proselytizing and SHOUTING. Don't include URLs to Web sites.
We do not edit comments. They are either approved or deleted. We reserve the right to edit a comment that is quoted or excerpted in an article. In this case, we may fix spelling and punctuation.
We welcome strong opinions and criticism of our work, but we don't want comments to become bogged down with discussions of our policies and we will moderate accordingly.
We appreciate it when readers and people quoted in articles or blog posts point out errors of fact or emphasis and will investigate all assertions. But these suggestions should be sent via e-mail. To avoid distracting other readers, we won't publish comments that suggest a correction. Instead, corrections will be made in a blog post or in an article.
- Reagan shooter Hinckley closer to permanent freedom
- Cole overcomes rough start as Pirates sweep Brewers
- Pirates notebook: GM sticking to plan with Kang
- Steelers won’t be backed into a corner at NFL Draft
- Pitt football notebook: ‘No. 1 safety’ Mitchell asked to step up
- Van crashes into deck in Scott, motorist taken to hospital
- Monessen man wounded in afternoon shooting
- U.S. attorney general nominee Lynch vote likely this week, U.S. senator says
- Coming off hill revives Seton Hill University, downtown Greensburg
- Khamenei says Iran nuclear weapons are U.S. ‘myth’
- Penn Hills soccer star makes time to excel at volleyball