| Home

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Decision to withhold Melvin's pay pending trial a rare move

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.
Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin speaks to reporters outside Pittsburgh Municipal Court after a hearing in May on charges she illegally used her state-funded staff to perform campaign work. AP
Related Stories

Daily Photo Galleries

Tuesday, Sept. 4, 2012, 12:01 a.m.

The state Court of Judicial Discipline employed an infrequently used but constitutionally supported sanction when it decided last week to withhold suspended state Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin's salary until her trial on corruption charges, experts said.

“Suspending a judge without pay is rare, but it's something we see all the time in other jobs,” said Philadelphia attorney Mark Rosen. “With the judiciary, it's an available sanction. It's just not often used.”

Melvin, 56, of Marshall faces seven charges, including four felonies, that she used her taxpayer-funded Superior Court staff illegally to campaign for a seat on the Supreme Court in 2003 and 2009. She pleaded not guilty to all charges.

In May, Melvin announced she was voluntarily recusing herself from any activity on the Supreme Court, the same day fellow justices suspended her with pay, ordered her office vacated, her staff sent home and her files and equipment secured.

Melvin's attorney, William “Skip” Arbuckle, said the decision “highlights the difficulty in making credibility decisions using a transcript rather than live witnesses.”

“That said, we respect the decision for what it is: an interim order and an interim order only.”

President Judge Robert E.J. Curran acknowledged that there are more cases in which the court has imposed an interim suspension without pay but disagreed that it had any bearing on Melvin's case.

“What (that) signifies is that this court has been reluctant to suspend without pay and has been careful to do so only in the most egregious cases,” he said. “We decide these cases one by one and we act on the totality of the circumstances as we see it in each case.”

Melvin will continue to receive medical benefits.

There are only a few cases in the court's 19-year history in which judges were suspended without pay. They include:

• Former state Supreme Court Justice Rolf Larsen in October 1993. The high court in 1993 removed Larsen months before an Allegheny County jury convicted him of conspiracy for having a state employee buy prescription drugs for his depression.

• Former Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph Jaffe in January 2003. He pleaded guilty to extorting $13,000 from an attorney who had 1,300 cases pending in Jaffe's courtroom. Jaffe used the money to pay off country club fees, medical bills and other debts.

Bruce Ledewitz, a Duquesne University law professor, said he hopes the decision will put economic pressure on Melvin, forcing her to resign from the high court, which has been hampered by having just six justices.

“I'm personally hoping this will force her off the bench; otherwise the (Supreme) Court will remain stymied,” Ledewitz said.

Without a conviction, Melvin can only be removed by the state Legislature or her resignation, he said.

Melvin will be tried with her sister and former staffer, Janine Orie, 58, of McCandless, who is charged with directing campaign work in Melvin's judicial office and in the office of a third sister, former state Sen. Jane Orie. A pre-trial conference is scheduled for Sept. 14. A trial date has not been set.

The family of Republicans has called the prosecution of the Orie sisters politically motivated, a claim that Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., a Democrat, denies. Jane Orie is serving 2 12 to 10 years in prison for her conviction on similar charges.

Adam Brandolph is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-391-0927 or

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Wilmerding targeted for mobile farmers market
  2. Steelers trying to get missing defensive pieces on field
  3. In reworking contract, Steelers WR Brown gets hefty pay raise
  4. Cole struggles as Brewers continue Miller mastery over Pirates
  5. Pirates notebook: 6 September call-ups include first-timer Diaz
  6. Steelers running back eager to prove he can help bridge gap to Bell
  7. Western Pa. played role, was transformed by victory in World War II
  8. Steelers’ Tomlin disappointed by Bryant suspension
  9. Steelers notebook: New kicker Scobee relishes opportunity
  10. Tenaska agrees to provide pollution information on proposed South Huntingdon plant
  11. PPG’s new CEO to push organic growth with existing clients