Pirates owner Nutting angry but keeps status quo in front office
By Rob Biertempfel
Published: Tuesday, November 6, 2012, 7:06 p.m.
Updated: Wednesday, November 7, 2012
After another second-half collapse stuck the Pirates with their 20th consecutive losing season, owner Bob Nutting considered firing the entire front office.
Although general manager Neal Huntington and his lieutenants were not purged, they will have to modify their approach to player acquisition and development. The first step, Nutting said, is abolishing the controversial, military-style drills for the club's minor leaguers.
During an hour-long interview Tuesday at PNC Park, Nutting revealed — in general terms — the findings of his ongoing personal evaluation of the Pirates' personnel and procedures. Nutting began the process after the Pirates tumbled from first place in the NL Central on July 18 to a 79-83 record good only for a fourth-place finish.
Nutting resisted a strong urge to make dramatic changes immediately after the season.
“Like every fan, I was angry,” Nutting said. “But that's not when you make your best decisions. If you're angry, you count to 10. If you're really angry, you count to 100. If you're incredibly infuriated and frustrated, you wait four weeks.”
Tuesday was the first time since mid-September that Nutting spoke publicly about the status of Huntington, assistant GMs Kyle Stark and Greg Smith, manager Clint Hurdle and president Frank Coonelly.
“We will not ever, nor should we ever, fall back on scapegoats,” Nutting said. “I will continue to be willing to make changes in personnel when appropriate and necessary. But in anger at the end of a season is the wrong time to judge someone's body of work and make decisions.”
Huntington was in transit Tuesday to the annual GM meetings in Indian Wells, Calif., and was unavailable for comment.
Nutting indicated he did not consider making piecemeal changes to the front office, which has been in place since Coonelly and Huntington were hired in September 2007.
“It is an extremely cohesive management team,” Nutting said.
Nutting conducted his own internal investigation, interviewing dozens of people inside and outside the team. He stressed that he was not done but rather that the timing isn't good for a move.
“What we have been doing and what we'll continue to do is a comprehensive review,” Nutting said. “But that is not a two-week or a four-week process. That is one that is going to continue as we evaluate every aspect of the organization. Because we need to get better.”
A series of reports in the Trib the past two months described the military training techniques instituted under Stark. Part of that was a Sept. 14-16 session instructed by former Navy SEALS in Bradenton, Fla., where outfield prospect Gregory Polanco reinjured his ankle during a drill involving water and sand. But the military mindset and practices have run year-round, including “Hell Week” conducted in October by the team's instructors.
The unusual drills have netted the Pirates criticism from fans, players, agents and others in the industry. It was enough to force Nutting to order a change of policy.
“Our primary focus is to develop baseball players to play championship baseball,” Nutting said. “That's the job of our development system. We are not a paramilitary organization. We should not be running a boot camp. We should be focusing on baseball drills.”
Although he has tweaked the club's procedures, Nutting said he will not take a more hands-on role in player acquisition and development decisions.
“I strongly believe my role needs to be getting the right (management) people, putting the systems in place and then holding them accountable,” Nutting said. “The worst mistakes baseball teams have made are when owners, out of frustration or ego or passion, step in and override baseball professionals.”
Rob Biertempfel is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org or 412-320-7811.
- Steelers quarterback Roethlisberger likes the revamped offense
- Steelers’ Polamalu trim, fit as he arrives for OTAs
- Pens’ Bylsma: Vitale scratch due to faceoff performance
- House on fire in Ohio Township
- Autocross benefit created in honor of late North Versailles woman gets on ‘Fast Track to a Cure’
- Hampton’s Walter making final pilgrimage
- North Hills senior has golden moment with writing competition
- Export officials put an end to the waiving of late fees
- Penguins Insider: Time is right for Jokinen’s return
- Tawdry tweet dogs Weiner’s campaign for New York City mayor
- Richland Elementary’s Farmer selected state substitute teacher of year
You must be signed in to add comments
To comment, click the Sign in or sign up at the very top of this page.
In order for a team to win the owner has to be able to identify "baseball people". Nutting has not been able to do that. He hired non-baseball people, that then surrounded themselves with people similar to them and the results are what they are... a disaster. The Pirates are thought of as a joke in the industry with a bunch of guys that are "smart on paper" but lack any feel for the game. These people should stick to working in the office and business side of things and let some of the real baseball people that know the game take over and run "BASEBALL OPERATIONS"! It will not be any better next year.
Submitted by: Russ on Wednesday, November 7, 2012
“The worst mistakes baseball teams have made are when owners, out of frustration or ego or passion, step in and override baseball professionals.” - Bob Nutting OK, so when is he going to hire some of these guys?