TribLIVE

| Home


Weather Forecast
 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Conservatism isn't dead

Daily Photo Galleries

By Jonah Goldberg
Saturday, Nov. 17, 2012, 8:57 p.m.
 

The conservative Gotterdammerung is finally here.

“Like dazed survivors in a ravaged city, America's conservatives are wailing and beating their collective breasts,” opines The Economist's “Lexington” columnist. “A leading conservative thinker,” asked by The Economist to “list today's conservative ideas, laughs bitterly and replies, ‘Are there any?'”

Former Reaganite Rep. Vin Weber (R-Minn.) laments in the conservative journal Policy Review, “I have never been so concerned about the future of conservative ideas.”

A Washington Post columnist announced that “the long descent of the Republican Party into irrelevance, defeat, and perhaps eventual disappearance” has finally begun.

William Kristol of The Weekly Standard concludes that the “conservative movement, which accomplished great things over the past quarter-century, is finished.” His magazine has dedicated an entire issue to the “conservative crack-up.”

These epitaphs are all from yesteryear. The bits from The Economist and Weber were in 1992. And Kristol delivered his death sentence after various conservatives lost the New Hampshire primary in 2000 (the “crack-up” issue was in 1997). The funereal Washington Post columnist? That was the late Robert Novak in 1976, four years before Ronald Reagan's 1980 triumph.

And that's just from the right. Since the conservative movement was born, liberals insisted it was dead. In 1956, Murray Kempton wrote in The Progressive that the “New American Right is most conspicuous these days for its advanced state of wither.” At least Kempton acknowledged it was conservative. That same year, John Fischer of Harper's insisted the founders of the new National Review were “the very opposite of conservative.”

In short, it's always Gotterdammerung somewhere on the right.

That's not to say that the conservative movement and the Republican Party are doing great. They're not. But whether fueled by left-wing glee or right-wing dread, rumors of the right's death are always exaggerated.

It's true that conservatives are more despondent than I've seen them in my lifetime. But that's in part because they've had things so good. There have been bumps but the story of the conservative movement has been one of fairly steady growth and success.

These successes were real and important. But they were not total because times change, and more to the point, total victories don't exist in politics so long as the losing side doesn't surrender.

Just for the record, I see dismay, even despair, out there. But I don't see much surrender.

Jonah Goldberg, author of “The Tyranny of Clichés,” is editor at large of National Review Online.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Jobs on state website include ‘private party dancing,’ ‘car dates’
  2. Former Steelers doctor loses bid for Miranda protection
  3. Fans flock to what they hope will continue ‘magical season’
  4. So Many Questions: Cary Elwes’s memoir offers a look at the filming of ‘The Princess Bride’
  5. Art Review: ‘Pittsburgh Biennial 2014’ at Carnegie Mellon University’s Miller Gallery
  6. Dining news: Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill unveils new menu
  7. Penguins notebook: Crosby ‘confident’ despite limited preseason time
  8. PennDOT to install art murals along Route 28
  9. Steelers’ Tomlin does not like his coaching style to be characterized
  10. Advocacy groups call for closer scrutiny of charter schools
  11. Steelers notebook: Tomlin bringing officials to practice
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.