| Home

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Security's price

Daily Photo Galleries

Thursday, Nov. 15, 2012, 9:01 p.m.

In the interest of national security, and the preservation of the world order the United States has upheld and benefited from since World War II, Republicans and Democrats must make the necessary compromises and agree on a deal to address the nation's fiscal crisis in both the near and the long term.

I am not an economist or a budget analyst, so I don't presume to know exactly what a “grand bargain” should look like. It seems pretty obvious that a compromise will require both tax reform and entitlement reform, since those programs are the biggest driver of the fiscal crisis.

What I do know, as a national security analyst, is that our continuing failure to address the crisis in a way that makes possible a return to stable economic growth has become a serious foreign policy problem.

In a world that still looks to U.S. leadership on many issues, our utter dysfunction on matters involving the basic health of our economy does not inspire confidence. Nor will the United States act with confidence abroad while we are unable to address our problems at home. It is no accident that all the misguided talk of a “post-American world” came after the financial crisis exploded.

A principal victim in the absence of a deal to address the fiscal crisis has been and will continue to be the national security budget. Republicans and Democrats alike have been prepared to see hundreds of billions of dollars cut from the defense budget, with even more cuts coming if Congress fails to avoid the automatic “sequestration.”

It would be one thing if the world were kindly affording us a period of placidity in international affairs while we get our house in order. But the world is not cooperating.

Iran continues to move closer to obtaining a nuclear weapon, and the prospect of a conflict cannot be dismissed.

The outcome of the Arab revolutions remains uncertain.

The tumult in Syria threatens to embroil the entire region.

The future of Afghanistan and nuclear-armed Pakistan remains worrying.

Terrorists continue to expand their efforts in the Middle East and Africa.

China's military is growing, and some forces in the Chinese system are pushing for greater assertiveness in the South China Sea and elsewhere.

We need to dispel the illusion that cuts to the national security budget really save us money. Too many think that if the United States simply scales back its role in the world, it could save money and make raising further revenue unnecessary.

This is a faulty assumption. The current global economic and political order, which has provided the environment in which the United States has grown and prospered for decades, is built on and around American power and influence.

Were the United States to cease playing its role in upholding this order, were we to retreat from East Asia or to back away from the challenge posed by a nuclear Iran, the result could only be global instability.

From a purely economic perspective, it would be far more costly to restore order and stability — both essential to a prosperous global economy — than it would be to sustain it.

The world won't stand still while Americans fight these political battles.

And it won't be forgiving of decisions that weaken our ability to defend the international order in which Americans have for so long prospered.

Robert Kagan is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. U.S. Steel to relocate corporate headquarters on former Civic Arena site
  2. Clues to Chief Justice John Roberts’ thinking on new ObamaCare case
  3. High winds, temperatures expected Monday in Western Pennsylvania
  4. Pirates trade Davis to A’s for international signing bonus money
  5. Finding balance between toughness, excessiveness key for Penguins’ Downie
  6. Starkey: No explaining Steelers, AFC North
  7. Bunny Mellon auction fetches $218 million
  8. NFL parity makes playoff chase a multi-team muddle
  9. For Steelers, a fight to finish for playoff berth
  10. CT scans can find smokers’ lung cancer early
  11. Obama announces Hagel resignation from Pentagon
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.