ShareThis Page
Food & Drink

Cookbook clubs cooking up good time for library patrons

Shirley McMarlin
| Saturday, July 15, 2017, 9:00 p.m.
Cookbook club organizer Robin Almendinger (right) samples some of the items brought by club members Monday, July 10 at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Cookbook club organizer Robin Almendinger (right) samples some of the items brought by club members Monday, July 10 at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Franny Guastaferro of Oakmont brings a dish of mac and cheese to the cookbook club Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Franny Guastaferro of Oakmont brings a dish of mac and cheese to the cookbook club Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Cookbook club members eat and share recipes during their potluck dinner Monday, July 10, at the  Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Cookbook club members eat and share recipes during their potluck dinner Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Some of the dishes made by the cookbook club members include four-cheese mac and cheese, smoked salmon dip, broccoli pineapple salad, chicken avacodo salad, chicken valentino and carrot cake for dessert  Monday, July 10, at the  Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Some of the dishes made by the cookbook club members include four-cheese mac and cheese, smoked salmon dip, broccoli pineapple salad, chicken avacodo salad, chicken valentino and carrot cake for dessert Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Cookbook club members (from left) Cindy O'Leary, Frank Almendinger and Sue Conroy sample some of the items brought by club members Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Cookbook club members (from left) Cindy O'Leary, Frank Almendinger and Sue Conroy sample some of the items brought by club members Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Franny Guastaferro of Oakmont checks out the recipe for chicken valentino at the cookbook club meeting on Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Franny Guastaferro of Oakmont checks out the recipe for chicken valentino at the cookbook club meeting on Monday, July 10, at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Deanna Mlynarczyk offers a collection of herbs to cookbook club members Monday, July 10, at the cookbook club meeting at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Jack Fordyce | Tribune-Review
Deanna Mlynarczyk offers a collection of herbs to cookbook club members Monday, July 10, at the cookbook club meeting at the Oakmont Carnegie Library.
Members of the Whitehall Public Library cookbook club enjoy a meal.
Whitehall Public Library
Members of the Whitehall Public Library cookbook club enjoy a meal.

“No food or beverages allowed,” that cardinal rule of libraries, doesn't always apply these days.

In recent years, tasting events sponsored by cookbook clubs have become popular at libraries around the area.

At the Carnegie Library of Pittsburgh Squirrel Hill branch, adult services librarian Maria Taylor says their club “was born out of the interest of the folks who use the library. We definitely have food lovers, and our cookbooks get checked out a lot.

“Most of our successful programming comes from ideas from our patrons.”

Their group meets quarterly, drawing “couples, singles, people from different cultures and ages,” Taylor says. Attendance is capped at 15 per meeting, and sessions are always full.

“That tells me maybe we need to be doing more of this,” she says.

Other Pittsburgh area libraries with cookbook clubs include Oakmont Carnegie Library, Whitehall Public Library and Shaler North Hills Library. In Westmoreland County, the Norwin and Ligonier Valley libraries have clubs.

The idea seems to have been passed from one to another.

“I got the idea from Green Tree (which no longer has a club) in 2010,” says Robin Almendinger, who does adult programming at Oakmont. “I ran with their concept and it's worked for us.”

In turn, Ligonier Valley library director Janet Hudson says she heard about the Oakmont group from one of its board members.

“I went to other library websites looking for program ideas, and saw that some were doing something similar,” says Diana Faulk, director of Norwin Public Library in Irwin.

“That's one thing about libraries,” Hudson says, “we share.”

Most sessions follow a similar format: A library staffer or club organizer will pick a cookbook from the library's collection and members will pick a recipe to prepare for the next meeting.

Often, the book is displayed near the circulation desk and participants mark the recipes they have chosen with a sticky note to avoid duplication.

The meeting begins with a tasting session, followed by a discussion of the food, the book and the individual recipes, including ease of preparation and finding ingredients.

Things work a bit differently in Squirrel Hill, Taylor says. There, a staff member places several cookbooks on hold for club members, who can check them out to try recipes at home.

“Then they come to talk about what they tried and how it worked,” she says.

For the meeting, Taylor prepares a couple of featured recipes for sampling. When the theme was non-dairy recipes, she made coconut whipped cream and non-dairy chocolate milkshakes.

“We ... have seen much more interest in these groups over the past five years,” says Judy Gelman, who, with Vicki Levy Krupp, wrote “The Book Club Cookbook” and created bookclubcookbook.com.

“We think a renewed interest in cooking — and cooking within a community around a common interest — fueled the initial surge in cookbooks clubs. Libraries, book stores, meet-up groups and other organizations have sponsored cookbook clubs around certain topics, increasing awareness of these groups,” Gelman says. “They provide a chance to try a number of recipes from a book, participate in a community event and explore a book in more depth, test cooking skills, sort through cooking challenges.

“Members tell us they try many recipes — and cookbooks — that they might have never explored on their own,” she adds.

“It's one of my favorite groups,” Faulk says about the Norwin Nibblers, who meet on the third Wednesday of the month.

“When we started, a lot of our people were not what they called cooks, but they wanted to learn about food and try new things,” she says. “We get people from their early 20s to their mid-80s.”

The various groups have tried cookbook staples from Betty Crocker and Pillsbury, along with ethnic and vegetarian cuisines and recipes from celebrity chefs.

“One of the hardest ones we did was a Martha Stewart book,” says Krista Brown, adult programming coordinator at Norwin. “A lot of the recipes were time-consuming or the ingredients were obscure. You had to buy a $10 bottle of something when you only needed a teaspoon.”

The Oakmont group encountered an unexpected result when they chose an Irish cookbook for a St. Patrick's Day gathering.

“Believe me, it was hard to find one of those in the system, and then we ended up with a lot of potato dishes,” Almendinger says. “In general, we pick (a cookbook) that's very general, something broad that includes everything from appetizers to desserts.”

While most discussions focus on the process of making the food and the end result, the group at Whitehall Public Library often takes it a step further.

“It's best when discussions become less about the food and more about what that food means to the person,” says adult services coordinator Brandon Taper in a post on bookclubcookbook.com. “How does preparing a meal affect your day differently from nuking a small box inside a larger box? How does the tactile process of cooking reveal itself in your life outside of the kitchen? ... Can food mean more than sustenance? Can it be art?”

“We go the whole nine yards,” Taper says. “We rate the cookbooks, talk about why the ingredients matter. Sometimes we'll chose a far-out theme. I don't think we've encountered any fear yet in trying new things.”

One memorable challenge was Katie Shelly's “Picture Cook,” in which drawings substitute for written instructions.

For some groups, the format has grown to activities and friendships beyond what Almendinger calls a “programmed potluck.”

At Whitehall, Taper has paired cuisines with movies, such as the obvious Greek with “My Big Fat Greek Wedding” and Asian and French with “The Hundred-Foot Journey.”

The Ligonier group has taken a bus trip to Pittsburgh's fresh-food mecca, the Strip District, and has a Christmas cookie exchange. Though the club is currently on hiatus, Hudson says she is considering trying to organize an eating club for periodic visits to local restaurants.

“I've been pleasantly surprised at how close our group has become,” Taper says. “But then, who doesn't like food?”

Shirley McMarlin is a Tribune-Review staff writer. Reach her at 724-836-5750, smcmarlin@tribweb.com or via Twitter @shirley_trib.

TribLIVE commenting policy

You are solely responsible for your comments and by using TribLive.com you agree to our Terms of Service.

We moderate comments. Our goal is to provide substantive commentary for a general readership. By screening submissions, we provide a space where readers can share intelligent and informed commentary that enhances the quality of our news and information.

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderating decisions are subjective. We will make them as carefully and consistently as we can. Because of the volume of reader comments, we cannot review individual moderation decisions with readers.

We value thoughtful comments representing a range of views that make their point quickly and politely. We make an effort to protect discussions from repeated comments either by the same reader or different readers

We follow the same standards for taste as the daily newspaper. A few things we won't tolerate: personal attacks, obscenity, vulgarity, profanity (including expletives and letters followed by dashes), commercial promotion, impersonations, incoherence, proselytizing and SHOUTING. Don't include URLs to Web sites.

We do not edit comments. They are either approved or deleted. We reserve the right to edit a comment that is quoted or excerpted in an article. In this case, we may fix spelling and punctuation.

We welcome strong opinions and criticism of our work, but we don't want comments to become bogged down with discussions of our policies and we will moderate accordingly.

We appreciate it when readers and people quoted in articles or blog posts point out errors of fact or emphasis and will investigate all assertions. But these suggestions should be sent via e-mail. To avoid distracting other readers, we won't publish comments that suggest a correction. Instead, corrections will be made in a blog post or in an article.

click me