| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Former Miss Pennsylvania must pay Donald Trump $5 million, arbiter rules


The Miss Universe 2012 Pageant airs at 8 p.m. Wednesday on NBC

Daily Photo Galleries

Tuesday, Dec. 18, 2012, 12:26 p.m.

A former Miss Pennsylvania USA 2012, who claimed a pageant was rigged, must pay billionaire Donald Trump $5 million for defaming the Miss Universe Organization, a New York arbitrator ruled.

Sheena Monnin, 27, of Cranberry in June resigned the state crown she won in December 2011. She accused Trump, the Miss USA Pageant's owner, of fixing the competition held in May in Las Vegas. Monnin claimed another contestant told her that she spotted a list of five finalists before the Top 15 selection began.

The raven-haired beauty queen then took to her Facebook page, calling the pageant “fraudulent, lacking in morals, inconsistent and in many ways trashy.”

The arbitrator, former U.S. District Court Magistrate Judge Theodore H. Katz, said Monnin's statements were false and “showed a reckless disregard” for the truth.

Monnin, who did not participate in the arbitration, could not be reached for comment. Her lawyer, Richard Klineburger of Philadelphia, did not return calls.

Katz said in a decision signed last week that the method for judging the pageant “precludes any reasonable possibility that the judging was rigged.” He said Monnin was disgruntled about not making it past preliminary rounds and objected to the pageant's decision to allow transgender contestants.

According to Katz, Monnin's allegations on Facebook and NBC's “Today” show cost the pageant a $5 million fee from a potential 2013 sponsor. However, Katz did not require Monnin to remove the online comments and found no evidence that she deliberately tried to destroy the pageant.

Albert Bates, an arbitrator and partner at the Downtown law firm Duane Morris, said it's difficult to vacate an arbitration award, because nearly all of the limited grounds to do so require proving fraud or corruption by the arbitrator.

“It is a binding process,” Bates said.

Randy Sanders, director of the Miss Pennsylvania pageant, was Monnin's manager from December 2011 until she resigned and said he hasn't spoken to her since. Sanders said Monnin insulted everyone involved with the pageant.

“She was accusing every one of those people of going along with something. We're talking about hundreds and hundreds of employees. She was taking a swipe at all of them, including me,” Sanders said. “It was insulting.”

Trump, in a statement, called Monnin's actions “disgraceful.” The New York tycoon known nationally from his NBC television show “The Apprentice,” suggested she fabricated the story because of “loser's remorse.” Miss Rhode Island Olivia Culpo won the Miss USA title.

“While I feel very badly for Sheena, she did the wrong thing. She was really nasty, and we had no choice. It is an expensive lesson for her,” Trump said.

Paula Shugart, president of Miss Universe Organization, said she is pleased the integrity of the pageant remains intact.

“Ms. Monnin could have avoided all of this had she chosen to act responsibly, rather than seeking her 15 minutes of fame. Her reckless actions affected many people,” Shugart said.

Sanders said he's glad to live in a country where people can speak freely, but “you have to be selective in how much you excercise that right. You have to have your facts in order. I think this decision verifies that.”

The Associated Press contributed. Adam Brandolph is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-391-0927 or




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. 2 dead, including student gunman, after Wash. school shooting
  2. Predators winger Neal caught ‘blindsided’ by trade from Penguins
  3. Ferrante trial: Cyanide order form in plain sight
  4. Howard Hanna family donates $1M for business student scholarships at University of Pittsburgh
  5. First Niagara sets aside $45 million
  6. Arrest made in connection with Rostraver home invasion
  7. Rossi: Middling Steelers must make a statement
  8. Steelers’ Adams delivers in pinch against Texans
  9. State’s ‘public-private’ transportation deal will replace 53 bridges in Allegheny County
  10. Monsour hospital properties sold at free-and-clear sale
  11. Counterfeit credit card ring falls for failure to remember birth date on fake ID
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.