TribLIVE

| News


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

NCAA argues Paterno family, others not eligible to sue it

AP
In this Aug. 6, 1999 file photo, Penn State head football coach Joe Paterno, right, poses with his defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky during Penn State Media Day at State College, Pa. A lawsuit by Joe Paterno's family and others against the NCAA went to court Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2013, one day after Penn State announced settlements with 26 young men over claims of abuse by Jerry Sandusky.

Daily Photo Galleries

By Anna Orso
Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2013, 4:06 p.m.
 

BELLEFONTE — Attorneys for the NCAA told a judge on Tuesday that the estate of former Penn State University football coach Joe Paterno and more than a dozen other plaintiffs lack legal standing to sue the governing body of college sports.

Judge John Leete heard oral arguments for more than three hours and will decide whether the case should move forward, though he did not say when he would rule. Among allegations he must consider are breach of contract, contract interference, defamation, civil conspiracy and commercial disparagement by the NCAA.

Four university trustees, four faculty members and a few former Penn State coaches and players joined the Paterno family in May to sue the NCAA.

They claim the NCAA erred when it imposed unprecedented sanctions on the football program in July 2012 because of the university's handling of the child sex abuse case against former assistant coach Jerry Sandusky.

Members of the Paterno family, including his son Scott, were in Centre County Court. Leete scheduled the hearing when the NCAA asked in July to toss the lawsuit.

Plaintiffs asked the court to invalidate a consent decree that Penn State President Rodney Erickson signed. The decree imposed penalties that include a four-year bowl ban, a reduction of scholarships, a $60 million fine and vacation of 111 wins while Paterno was head coach.

The NCAA agreed last month to reinstate some scholarships faster than it initially intended.

Everett Johnson, an attorney for the NCAA, said invalidating the consent decree would open the school to another investigation and potentially harsher penalties.

Anthony Lubrano, a Penn State trustee and plaintiff, said after the hearing that he thinks that's a hollow threat and believes the NCAA didn't have jurisdiction to impose penalties.

The plaintiffs argued the NCAA was not within its rights to sanction Penn State because the association did not follow its bylaws and independently investigate. It levied sanctions based on a university-commissioned investigation that concluded Paterno and other administrators didn't do enough to stop Sandusky from molesting boys.

“They were acting completely in uncharted waters with nothing whatsoever to support them on it,” said Joseph Loveland, attorney for the plaintiffs.

Penn State is not a party in the lawsuit and waived its right to bring legal action against the NCAA when Erickson signed the decree. However, the NCAA argued that in order for the judge to render a decision, Penn State would have to be a party in the lawsuit because the outcome would directly affect its rights.

“There's a big, missing elephant in this room, and that's Penn State University,” Johnson said.

Attorneys for the NCAA declined to comment after the hearing.

Penn State on Monday announced it settled with 26 men who claimed abuse by Sandusky. The settlements totaled about $59.7 million.

Sandusky, 69, is serving a 30- to 60-year prison sentence for abusing 10 boys in and around the Penn State campus and his State College home.

Three former Penn State administrators await trial on charges they knowingly covered up the abuse. Paterno died in January 2012 of complications from lung cancer.

Anna Orso is a freelance reporter based in State College.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Foreign influx in Allegheny County at ‘tipping point’
  2. 1 intruder killed, other shot and wounded in Carrick home invasion
  3. Route 28 motorists to face new traffic configuration starting Wednesday
  4. TSA finds .380-caliber handgun in carry-on bag at Pittsburgh International Airport
  5. Steelers hope group of low-budget cornerbacks can deliver
  6. GM Colbert expects Roethlisberger to end career with Steelers
  7. Rostraver youth pastor accused of sexual contact with teen girl
  8. Steelers WR Wheaton wants to produce after injury-plagued rookie year
  9. Roethlisberger ‘prays’ he can stay with Steelers when deal expires
  10. Judge won’t dismiss charges of assaulting Pittsburgh police officer
  11. Photo gallery: Jack White takes crowd at Pittsburgh’s Stage AE by storm
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.