| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Kane supports Trib's request to open court records in sting operation

Email Newsletters

Sign up for one of our email newsletters.
Tyron B. Ali, a former Philadelphia day-care president, became an informant posing as a lobbyist in a sting on Pennsylvania lawmakers.


Justice Clarence Thomas agreed with the outcome of the case, but wrote separately to say that he would have gone further and wiped away all contribution limits.

Advocating the overruling of the 1976 Buckley v. Valeo decision that upheld contribution limits:

“Contributions and expenditures are simply two sides of the same First Amendment coin, and our efforts to distinguish the two have produced mere word games rather than any cognizable principle of constitutional law.”

“This case represents yet another missed opportunity to right the course of our campaign finance jurisprudence by restoring a standard that is faithful to the First Amendment.”


Justice Stephen Breyer, writing for the dissenting side, took the unusual step of reading a summary of his opinion from the bench.

“It understates the importance of protecting the political integrity of our governmental institutions. It creates a loophole that will allow a single individual to contribute millions of dollars to a political party or to a candidate's campaign. Taken together with Citizens United v FEC, today's decision eviscerates our nation's campaign finance laws, leaving a remnant incapable of dealing with the grave problems of democratic legitimacy that those laws were intended to resolve.”

“Where enough money calls the tune, the general public will not be heard.”

“Democracy, the court has often said, cannot work unless the people have faith in those who govern.”

Daily Photo Galleries

Wednesday, April 2, 2014, 12:57 p.m.

HARRISBURG — Attorney General Kathleen Kane will file court papers in support of the Tribune-Review's request to open sealed records from a sting operation against Philadelphia lawmakers, her office said on Wednesday.

“I applaud the Tribune-Review's motion to unseal the records to allow the public to see all the information, and will be filing a response in support of the newspaper's motion,” Kane said. “All of the facts will show the public that this investigation, left over from three previous administrations, was critically flawed and could not have been prosecuted.”

Kane's office said the document was not filed by the end of the day.

The Trib on Monday asked a Dauphin County judge for permission to intervene and attempt to open records in the case involving five Democratic officials who accepted cash from a confidential informant for the attorney general's office. Four are legislators. The informant, Tyron B. Ali, wore a wire and recorded the encounters.

President Judge Todd Hoover on Tuesday unsealed the Trib's motion, giving Kane and Ali's attorney, Robert Levant, five days to respond.

Levant declined to comment.

House leaders from both political parties on Wednesday imposed a ban on cash gifts. The Bipartisan Management Committee acted in response to the scandal involving the legislators and a former traffic court judge, which The Philadelphia Inquirer reported last month.

The Senate expects to take up a gift ban as soon as next week.

Lawmakers must report gifts in the aggregate of more than $250 and hospitality of $650 or more. They must report gifts of larger amounts on financial disclosure statements filed with the state ethics commission. No specific prohibition against cash exists.

As the new House policy was being distributed through a one-page memo, Democratic gubernatorial candidate Katie McGinty held a news conference at the Capitol calling for a gift ban for all state elected officials and employees.

McGinty said public indignation over the scandal is at a “fever pitch,” resulting in a “tipping point” for broad legislative action to prohibit gifts — except for those from close family members and established friends who are not lobbyists or doing business with the state.

The House rule would not cover all gifts, even debit cards or gift cards, which are virtually cash equivalents.

“The immediate need was to address cash,” said Stephen Miskin, a House Republican spokesman. “We expect more to come at some point.”

Republican Gov. Tom Corbett, speaking at a Harrisburg hotel after addressing an early childhood learning conference, said he supports a ban on cash gifts.

“I was stunned that somebody would actually accept cash and, if they just reported it, would be OK,” Corbett said. “Certainly, that can't be allowed. Or gift cards.”

If Hoover grants the Trib's motion, the newspaper will push for unsealing of criminal court documents in the state's case against Ali. Prosecutors used a fraud case as leverage to gain his cooperation as an informant. The state had 2,088 charges against the former day care center operator for scamming the Department of Education.

Kane dropped the charges, saying a deal struck with Ali and his lawyer before she took office gave her no choice.

Other newspapers, including The Philadelphia Inquirer, followed the Trib's motion to unseal the case.

The extraordinarily lenient plea deal with Ali undermined his credibility as a witness, Kane has said. She has said that Bruce Beemer, former chief of staff to ex-Attorney General Linda Kelly, was unaware of the investigation. Beemer heads the criminal division for Kane.

Kelly told the Trib that in cases in which no charges were filed, though prosecution may have been contemplated, it was her policy “to not discuss or make statements in a public forum” about an investigation, its targets or witnesses.

That's in “deference to the rights of individuals who might be subject to charges” and to “not interfere with or compromise” due process in a court.

“Therefore, I have no comment on a case that has not been charged,” Kelly said. Asked if she knew about the sting operation, she said: “I can only say the statement speaks for itself.”

A 2012 memo the Trib obtained about a long-range plan for the sting was addressed to Kelly and other senior prosecutors.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.Brad Bumsted is Trib Total Media's state Capitol reporter. Reach him at 717-787-1405 or

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Penguins co-owner Lemieux snuffs rumored rift with Crosby
  2. Steelers notebook: Tomlin ends practice with third-down work
  3. Duquesne basketball tops Western Kentucky to win consolation bracket
  4. Pirates sign free agent 1B-OF Goebbert, RHP Webster
  5. Explosion claims life of garage owner
  6. Attorney wants evidence from South Allegheny teacher’s cellphone thrown out
  7. WPIAL AAAA boys basketball preview: Runners-up last season, North Allegheny hopes to take next step
  8. Stocks finish weak before Thanksgiving holiday; energy firms give back some gains
  9. Steelers kicker Boswell puts best foot forward
  10. Steelers notebook: Tomlin not grooming successor to RB Williams
  11. Dining at Applebee’s helps Jacobs Creek Area Faith in Action