| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Veteran accused in shooting at Washington grocery acted in self-defense, attorney says

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.
Brandon Thomas, 32, of Upper St. Clair is accused of shooting a Chartiers man to death after what authorities described as a road-rage incident.

Daily Photo Galleries

'American Coyotes' Series

Traveling by Jeep, boat and foot, Tribune-Review investigative reporter Carl Prine and photojournalist Justin Merriman covered nearly 2,000 miles over two months along the border with Mexico to report on coyotes — the human traffickers who bring illegal immigrants into the United States. Most are Americans working for money and/or drugs. This series reports how their operations have a major impact on life for residents and the environment along the border — and beyond.

By Bobby Kerlik
Monday, May 12, 2014, 11:39 a.m.

There's no question an Army veteran of the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq fatally shot a man in a Washington County parking lot, his attorney told a jury on Monday, but jurors should acquit him because he did it in self-defense.

The trial of Brandon Thomas, 32, of Upper St. Clair began in Washington County before a crowded courtroom. A jury of six men and six women must decide whether the former staff sergeant was justified in killing Vaughn Simonelli, 55, of Chartiers after a driving incident on Oct. 18, 2012, outside the Shop 'n Save in Washington.

Thomas is charged with homicide and three counts of possessing drug paraphernalia.

Calling Simonelli an “angry, deranged person,” Thomas' attorney, Frank Walker, said his client was defending himself following an argument that Simonelli started.

“As a self-defense-trained veteran, he pulls out a lawfully concealed firearm to defend himself,” Walker said of Thomas.

Prosecutors don't see it that way. First Assistant District Attorney Chad Schneider is seeking a conviction of first- or third-degree murder or manslaughter. He said Simonelli was shot once in the shoulder and once in the back.

“(Thomas) also had packets used for heroin transportation in his boot,” Schneider said.

Recollections of what happened differed among witnesses who testified. Prosecutors contend Thomas drove recklessly down the center turning lane on Jefferson Avenue in a black Hummer, passing cars until he got to a red light.

Simonelli, who was behind Thomas at the light, got out of his car and yelled at Thomas.

When the light turned green, Thomas drove off and turned into the supermarket parking lot. Simonelli followed and blocked in Thomas' vehicle once he pulled into a spot.

Roger Anderson, 71, testified he walked out of the store and saw both men out of their cars, arguing. He said Thomas was saying he had to leave because he had a family member in the hospital and went to get into his Hummer.

“(Simonelli) approached the door and said, ‘You're not going nowhere,' and he threw a punch,” Anderson said. “Then, I heard two shots immediately after. I ran over and said, ‘You didn't have to shoot him.' ”

John McGary, 73, who was heading to the grocery store, said he heard the argument and saw Thomas waving his gun — a Ruger pistol — over Simonelli's head.

“(Thomas) was using the F-word, saying, ‘I have a child in the hospital, and I have to get out of here.' He put his gun in his holster and went toward his Hummer. Once the fella got in the Hummer, the other man started toward him,” said McGary, who heard shots seconds later.

Thomas has a wife and three children. Walker said his client made up the story about the sick child to get away from Simonelli.

Thomas has support from former comrades, said Army Warrant Officer Jeremiah Minor, who plans to testify on Tuesday as a character witness.

The two served together in the 173rd Airborne Infantry in Afghanistan, where Minor said Thomas saved his life. Their platoon came under heavy Taliban fire and Minor was the forward observer, whose job was to give coordinates of incoming fire to Thomas, who was returning mortar fire.

“Everyone was duck-and-cover, but he stood by my side and waited for me to get my coordinates. If he would have left me, there would have been no one to return fire,” said Minor, 36, who drove from Cincinnati for the trial.

Minor and Walker said Thomas was honorably discharged in 2010 and has three Purple Heart medals.

Minor views the case as clear-cut self-defense.

“Any soldier in his situation would have done the exact same thing,” Minor said. “If he was a little old lady, we wouldn't be here.”

Bobby Kerlik is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-320-7886 or

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Police: Escaped Armstrong County inmate armed, dangerous homicide suspect
  2. Pirates bolster bullpen by trading for former closer Soria
  3. Pirates’ Burnett endures another poor start in blowout loss to Reds
  4. Inside the Steelers: Rookie linebacker Chickillo continues to excel
  5. Steelers’ reserve quarterbacks vie to secure spot behind Roethlisberger, Gradkowski
  6. Warrant issued for man accused of killing Brookline woman
  7. Steelers stress improved conditioning in attempt to play past injuries
  8. Pirates notebook: Blanton introduced; Worley designated for assignment
  9. Emails among Governor Wolf’s aides reveal concern over AG Kane
  10. Heyl: Longtime disc jockey Jimmy Roach to turn dismissal into brighter times
  11. Steelers notebook: Tomlin says Latrobe session won’t differ from normal practice