UPMC analysis contends Highmark no longer top insurer in Western Pa.
More people in Western Pennsylvania now have health insurance from UPMC than from Highmark Inc., according to a UPMC analysis, marking a potential milestone in the rivalry between the nonprofits.
Highmark, which for decades has dominated the region's health insurance market, declined to say Thursday whether it has arrived at the same conclusion.
“Highmark will be announcing our enrollment numbers over the next few weeks, and we will be eager to share our 2016 enrollment statistics,” spokesman Aaron Billger wrote in a statement. “It's never been our practice to comment on competitors' enrollment.”
UPMC's analysis, announced Thursday, shows UPMC Health Plan grew from about 813,000 members in 2014 to 1,095,000 members in 2016. It shows Highmark's enrollment for the same period shrank from 1,419,000 to 1,092,000.
Each insurer has about 28 percent of the Western Pennsylvania market, which covers 29 counties, according to the analysis. The numbers represent a major shift from five years ago, when Highmark had 60 percent of the market, UPMC spokesman Paul Wood said.
“I think what we've moved from is one of the least competitive markets to one of the most competitive markets in the nation,” said Diane Holder, president and CEO of UPMC Health Plan.
Other insurers, including Aetna and UnitedHealthcare, collectively account for 29 percent of the market, with traditional Medicare and the uninsured making up the remaining 15 percent. Aetna and United declined to comment on the analysis.
Holder said UPMC sold more plans by offering competitive pricing and attractive networks of hospitals and doctors.
UPMC's tally combines the commercial, individual, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed-care markets. UPMC did not break down the numbers for each market, but Holder said UPMC Health Plan had gained the largest amount of market share in the noncommercial plans such as Medicaid and in plans sold on the Affordable Care Act's online marketplace.
The undifferentiated total raises questions about whether UPMC Health Plan's gain in market share will translate to net income, said Stephen Foreman, an associate professor of health care administration at Robert Morris University.
UPMC Health Plan's share of the Affordable Care Act marketplace grew from 18 percent at the end of the 2014-15 open enrollment period to 67 percent at the end of the 2015-16 enrollment period, Wood said. The enrollment period ended Jan. 31.
Highmark might not mind losing some of those enrollees whose medical bills were much more expensive than the premiums they paid in 2015, Foreman said. Highmark reported losing $318 million on the ACA market in the first half of 2015, a loss the insurer attributed to sicker-than-expected people signing up for the insurance.
The insurer increased premiums for the open enrollment period, allowing UPMC Health Plan to offer the lowest-cost “silver” plan, a popular midlevel plan.
UPMC did not say how many enrollees in its Medicaid managed-care plan, UPMC For You, it is counting. UPMC dominates the Medicaid market in Western Pennsylvania, which has greatly expanded since Gov. Tom Wolf expanded Medicaid in the state to include all individuals who make up to about $16,000 per year. State data show UPMC For You had 240,000 members in December in a 14-county region in Southwestern Pennsylvania. Gateway Health, a Medicaid managed-care plan in which Highmark has a stake, had about 126,000 members.
Low reimbursement rates for Medicaid make it difficult for insurers to make money through the program.
“My overall impression is that they well could have taken on more membership, but is it really good? Is it paying enrollment or is it enrollment they're going to lose money on down the road,” Foreman said.
Billger said Highmark has retained 94 percent of its members among employers in Western Pennsylvania, while retaining 95 percent of its Medicare Advantage members.
“If these numbers are accurate, I didn't expect the market would be this close this fast,” said James McTiernan, area vice president for national consulting firm Arthur J. Gallagher. “I think UPMC has done very well in the small groups or for individuals. UPMC may have the most attractive programs rate-wise.”
Still, McTiernan did not think UPMC's announcement translates to crippling financial hardship for Highmark.
“The world has changed for Highmark, and they are dealing with it,” he said. “Right now, both UPMC and Highmark can make equally eloquent arguments as to why they are better than the other. Over the long run we will see what networks performs best when it comes to cost, quality and access. That's going to take awhile.”
UPMC said its analysis was based on data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Pennsylvania's Department of Human Services , the 2010 census and other sources.
Also Thursday, UPMC announced $201 million in operating income for the six months ending Dec. 31, up from $192 million for the same period a year earlier.
Wes Venteicher and Ben Schmitt are Tribune-Review staff writers.