Former Pa. jail guard to serve term in Ohio facility
By Adam Brandolph
Published: Wednesday, March 20, 2013, 11:48 p.m.
Updated: Wednesday, March 20, 2013
A former Allegheny County Jail guard convicted of beating an inmate cannot stay in a community correctional facility because, in part, its administrators cannot guarantee his safety.
U.S. District Judge Gustave Diamond on Wednesday ordered James Donis, 50, of Shaler to serve part of his sentence in a facility run by Community Corrections Association in Youngstown, Ohio.
“I don't see where I have an alternative,” Diamond said. “Home confinement was not acceptable because it would not promote respect for the law.”
Donis, once the fourth-in-command at the jail, pleaded guilty in October to beating inmate Gary W. Barbour in April 2010 and later falsifying reports to cover it up. In February, Diamond sentenced Donis to five years of probation and eight months at Renewal Inc., a Downtown community correctional facility.
Administrators at Renewal refused to accept Donis because some residents are former inmates from the jail, Donis knows some of the guards, and their policy prohibits residents from working for family members. Donis planned to hold a job at Perrytowne Drafthouse in Ross, which his wife owns.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Amy L. Johnston said neither Renewal nor CCA would permit Donis to work at his wife's business because there was little oversight to verify whether he showed up each day.
Donis' attorney Charles Porter argued it would be difficult for Donis to find a job that pays a convicted felon $50,000 a year.
“I don't think it's reasonable,” Porter told the judge. “This makes zero sense.”
Porter said he was not sure if he'll appeal the decision because Donis “wants to move on with his life.”
Authorities said Donis punched Barbour several times in the face after he bungled an escape attempt. A year later, when Donis learned the FBI was investigating, he prepared a false addendum to his report saying Barbour was “combative” and “refused to comply with commands.” The U.S. Attorney's Office charged Donis in November 2011.
On March 14, federal Magistrate Lisa Pupo Lenihan ordered two former high-ranking jail officials, Thomas Leicht, the ex-chief of Internal Affairs at the jail, and Lance Bohn, the former No. 2 leader, to be joined to Barbour's civil lawsuit against the county.
Bohn, 42, of Swissvale, who blamed Donis for the beating and other guards for failing to stop it, admitted to federal investigators that he was in a utility room when Donis beat Barbour and was granted immunity from prosecution. Leicht, 50, was forced out of his job in 2011. He told FBI agents that officials above him lied about the incident.
Adam Brandolph is a staff writerfor Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-391-0927 or email@example.com.Staff writer Carl Prine contributed to this report.
- County executive: Allegheny risks losing millions with delayed decision on park drilling
- National study: College teacher training is ‘industry of mediocrity’
- Newsmaker: Jessica Vega-Rogowicz
- Small communication firms target system
- Sentencing postponed in Pitt online threats case
- Pittsburgh police, civilian employees to work convention
- VA had Legionella bug 5 years before disclosure
- Corbett administration seeking assurances state won’t be left holding Medicaid bag
- Sewickley church can repurpose ‘pink house’ to fellowship center
- Facial recognition technology moving toward identifying almost anyone
- Newsmaker: Jennifer Moss
You must be signed in to add comments
To comment, click the Sign in or sign up at the very top of this page.
Bohn, 42, of Swissvale, who blamed Donis for the beating and other guards for failing to stop it, admitted to federal investigators that he was in a utility room when Donis beat Barbour and was granted immunity from prosecution. Leicht, 50, was forced out of his job in 2011. He told FBI agents that officials above him lied about the incident. I believe the paragraph above pretty much sums things up. Two former employees take a fall for this moron because they told the truth... Who should really be in jail was the former Warden who was running the place knowing exactly what was going on. What's he do ?? He see''s the hand writing on the wall and finds a job in New Mexico and runs as quick as he could because he was the next one to be fired. Donis should be serving a jail sentence and not a get a slap on the wrist like he did. He's pissed because he can't work at "HIS" bar now for those 8 months. Poor guy... Maybe see how it is to work at McDonalds for minimum wage and get a real feel for how others have it ... Without beating on others and lying.