| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Allegheny County Council mulls ban on project labor deals

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.
By Bobby Kerlik
Wednesday, April 3, 2013, 12:01 a.m.

Allegheny County Council is considering a proposal to ban project labor agreements for businesses bidding on county contracts.

Councilman Matt Drozd, R-Ross, introduced the plan at Tuesday's council meeting, saying PLAs discriminate against nonunion businesses and drive up costs to taxpayers.

“I'm not anti-union, but let's level the playing field,” he said. “It costs the taxpayers more than they should pay for projects.”

Such union agreements guarantee healthy wages and benefits, usually in exchange for assurances that workers won't go on strike if there's a labor dispute. Critics say the deals provide a means for politicians to repay unions for political campaign support.

Council President Charles Martoni referred the plan to a committee for discussion.

Tension over the use of project labor agreements in county projects is not new. The Associated Builders of Western Pennsylvania filed a lawsuit in 2010 seeking to halt bidding on construction of Community College of Allegheny County's $21.5 million K. Leroy Irvis Science Center, claiming the inclusion of a PLA required the use of mostly union labor. An Allegheny County judge rejected the claims in 2011.

Frank Sirianni, president of the Pennsylvania State Building and Construction Trades Council, disputed that PLAs drive up costs or limit competition.

“It requires qualified contractors. The beauty of a PLA is that it outlines the general construction process, sets hours, standards. It's a tool to be used,” Sirianni said. “It also sets benchmarks and guarantees local workers. PLAs are open to all contractors.”

Eileen Watt, president of the Associated Builders of Western Pennsylvania, said she supported Drozd's move and that PLAs cut out competition.

“Nonunion contractors are taxpayers as well. They should not be eliminated from the bidding process,” she said.

Bobby Kerlik is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-320-7886 or

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Allegheny

  1. Pittsburgh zoo receives $9M gift — largest ever — from Mellon Foundation
  2. Upper St. Clair lifeguard ordered to stand trial for rape of female lifeguard
  3. Founder of Operation Safety Net in Pittsburgh named one of CNN’s 2015 Top 10 Heroes
  4. North Hills transit service limits lamented
  5. Downtown Pittsburgh Macy’s donates bits of history
  6. Siblings sue over gas rights in Jefferson Hills land parcel
  7. Former employee at Plum home-building firm charged with embezzling nearly $200K
  8. Allegheny County Sheriff’s deputies apprehend one of county’s ‘most wanted fugitives’
  9. 30 federal prisoners in W.Pa. on list for early release; 27 in Pittsburgh
  10. Bishop Zubik visits Mooncrest Community Center
  11. Police looking for man who sexually assaulted Squirrel Hill woman