| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Lack of physical evidence could hinder doctor's prosecution, attorneys say

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.
Related Stories
Friday, July 26, 2013, 12:01 a.m.

Pittsburgh police quoted 10 unnamed witnesses in laying out their evidence linking UPMC Dr. Robert J. Ferrante to the cyanide poisoning death of his wife, Dr. Autumn Klein.

Attorneys who are not involved in the case noted that none of those witnesses says he or she actually saw a crime occur.

“It's an absolutely, totally circumstantial case,” said Patrick Thomassey, who has defended clients in some of Allegheny County's highest-profile murder cases. “I'm not so sure that the case gets to a jury.”

The police affidavit includes descriptions of Ferrante's behavior and his purchase of cyanide.

“So what? That doesn't say he did anything,” Thomassey responded. “A jury is going to be very reluctant to convict a person of that stature.”

Defense attorney Frank Walker noted that prosecutors sometimes hold back evidence at this stage and might have more.

“With what I've heard, I'd attack the lack of physical evidence,” he said.

Walker said Ferrante's defense strategy likely will focus on trying to determine the identity of the witnesses.

“Who are they? Do they themselves have any motive?” he said. “In these husband-wife cases, the surviving spouse is always the first suspect.”

Thomassey said the defense should play up Ferrante's position in the community, his education and intelligence.

“Is a guy who's this successful going to stoop this low and be this dumb to ruin his life and career over something like this?” Thomassey asked. “It's baffling. There's so many easier ways to have someone killed.

“It does not sound like a strong case.”

David Conti is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 412-388-5802 or

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Allegheny

  1. Shell, Center water authority reach agreement on relocating water source
  2. Friends say Baldwin Borough couple in murder-suicide was depressed
  3. Road crews are dealing with oil and sealant spills on roadways
  4. Fans connect with their beloved Buccos through homemade signs
  5. Authorities identify McKeesport man whose body was found in Yough River
  6. Philadelphia murder suspect nabbed in Braddock
  7. Witness tells jury about fatal McKeesport shooting
  8. Canon-McMillan drops U.S. Postal Service from condemnation action
  9. 2 men arrested at UPMC McKeesport on charges of endangering teens
  10. $20M bond issue could cost cash-strapped Penn Hills School District $6.6M in interest
  11. Roads to close on Pittsburgh’s North Side this weekend