| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Pittsburgh council members take advantage of 'walking around money'

What the dollars buy

Pittsburgh City Council members spend up to $8,000 annually in taxpayer-provided discretionary funds on gift baskets, athletic apparel and more, a sampling of invoices shows:

• Ricky Burgess, who represents East End communities: $5,190 on a temporary staffer, Alice Mason of Downtown, to provide constituent services. He has two full-time staffers.

“It's to enhance my constituent services so that most people who call receive a live voice instead of voice mail,” he said.

• Former Councilman Patrick Dowd, who represented Lawrenceville, Polish Hill and a number of East End neighborhoods: $1,000 to the Lawrenceville United civic group for pole banners and portable sidewalk signs at a farmers market. Dowd declined to comment.

• Theresa Kail-Smith, who represents the West End: $500 donation to Windgap-Chartiers City Civic Club for a “Back to School” festival. Smith said she gives money to organizations that work to improve neighborhoods and are not eligible for other funding.

“A lot of these groups do work in our communities that we couldn't do without them,” she said.

• Bruce Kraus, who represents the South Side: $2,400 for a temporary staffer, Matthew Stidle of Troy Hill, to help craft legislation.

“I spend it in ways that will reap long-term benefits — meetings in Harrisburg, promoting responsible gun ownership, underage drinking, writing legislation that we can use to get through to those things.”

• R. Daniel Lavelle, who represents the Hill District, Downtown and part of the North Side: $175 to buy shorts for a Hill District youth basketball team. He could not be reached for comment.

• Corey O'Connor, who represents East End neighborhoods: $200 donation to the Monongahela Marsden Block Association in Hazelwood to help buy a commercial lawn mower for vacant lot maintenance.

“I don't think my name's on the lawn mower,” he said.

• Natalia Rudiak, who represents South Hills neighborhoods: $150 for three gift baskets for a charity raffle benefiting Meals on Wheels and the Make-A-Wish Foundation. She could not be reached for comment.

Sunday, Oct. 27, 2013, 9:00 p.m.

Pittsburgh City Council President Darlene Harris will treat hundreds of North Side kids to peanut butter crackers costing $441 this Halloween at the expense of taxpayers.

Spending her discretionary money on such things is a cheap and equitable way to provide needed help to civic groups — plus, other elected officials do it — Harris said.

Spreading around so-called walking around money is a tactic politicians statewide use to raise their profile with constituents, said Barry Kauffman, executive director of Pennsylvania Common Cause, a fiscal watchdog group.

“It is all part of a taxpayer-funded incumbency protection racket,” Kauffman said.

Pittsburgh budgets $8,000 annually for each of nine City Council members to spend at their discretion. The money comes with no stipulations for its usage, solicitor Dan Regan said.

So council members spend some or all of it on “goodwill” causes: baskets for charity auctions, shirts for youth sports leagues, cash donations for parades and the like, their invoices show.

Regan said Harris' Halloween purchase is legitimate. “There's nothing that would prohibit” that, he said.

Though the practice dates back decades — the late Councilman Duane Darkins offered turkeys to constituents at Thanksgiving — some past council members went to court for misusing discretionary money.

Former Councilwoman Twanda Carlisle pleaded no contest to theft and related charges and went to prison in 2007 for a $43,000 kickback scheme that funded personal purchases, including a fur coat and money for friends.

Matt Hogue, former aide to Councilman Bruce Kraus, pleaded guilty to theft and received five years of probation last year for selling $10,000 worth of chain saws that Kraus' office bought for community groups to clean up vacant lots.

Harris said she uses her money to support community groups that otherwise couldn't pay for events and improvements.

Pete Bellisario, president of the Brighton Heights Citizen's Federation, which received some of the treats she bought for its annual Halloween festival, said Harris is a supportive politician.

“If we didn't have her, we'd have to do fundraising,” he said. “We've tried that before, and fundraising isn't the easiest thing to do.”

Harris said distributing crackers is cheaper than giving each of 21 organizations in her district a $50 or $100 donation, and it's equitable because everyone receives something to give away at Halloween.

She said she has donated the crackers for years and buys candy canes at Christmas.

“I'm not doing anything different than what other people do,” she said. “State representatives and senators pass out coloring books with their names on them.”

Kauffman said politicians should at least be honest about who foots the bill.

“Shouldn't it say, ‘Paid for by the taxpayers of Pittsburgh'?” he said of the crackers.

Councilman Bill Peduto said he co-sponsored legislation after the Carlisle scandal to limit use of discretionary money. The bill failed for lack of support, he said.

Peduto, who is favored to become mayor in November's election, used about $2,800 for a temporary office staffer, Dan Groberg of Shadyside, during his primary election campaign. He said his office needed someone to serve constituents while he campaigned to win the Democratic nomination. He has two full-time staffers.

“It really comes down, at this point, to a decision of the individual council members on how they spend these funds,” Peduto said.

Bob Bauder is a Trib Total Media staff writer. He can be reached at 412-765-2312 or




Show commenting policy

Most-Read Allegheny

  1. Pennsylvania constables need oversight to reduce problems, officials say
  2. Newsmaker: Enrique Mu
  3. Pittsburgh student jailed after striking school police officer
  4. Investors eager to trade cash for green cards in immigration program
  5. Pittsburgh Holocaust Center finally finds permanent home
  6. Legal response refutes claims of late Tribune-Review owner’s children to trusts
  7. Bridge work to cause early morning traffic stoppages on Parkway West off-ramp in Carnegie
  8. Wolf appoints 7 from Western Pennsylvania to his transition team
  9. Body found on Clairton Boulevard in Pleasant Hills
  10. U.S. Marshals arrest man wanted in fatal Penn Hills shooting
  11. Pittsburgh police to test new ‘ShotSpotter’ gunshot-detection system
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.