TribLIVE

| News


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Ex-coach who arranged player injury seeks retrial or chance to appeal in Fayette court

About Bob Stiles
Picture Bob Stiles 724-836-6622
Staff Reporter
Tribune-Review

Daily Photo Galleries


By Bob Stiles

Published: Saturday, Oct. 5, 2013, 12:01 a.m.

A former T-ball coach who was found guilty of arranging to injure an autistic player is asking Fayette County Court for a new trial or to allow him an appeal to state Superior Court.

Mark R. Downs Jr., 36, formerly of South Union, contends in a motion filed on Friday that his counsel was ineffective.

A hearing has been scheduled for Oct. 20 before Judge Ralph Warman.

Downs, who is being housed in SCI-Retreat, made national headlines in 2005 when he was accused of arranging to have one of his T-ball players injure the autistic player. The 8-year-old player testified his first toss bounced off the ground and hit the autistic boy in the groin, and Downs told him to “try hitting him harder in the face.”

At trial, Downs testified that the case was a misunderstanding and that the ball-thrower and his family were lying.

Downs was convicted in 2006 of corruption of minors and conspiracy to commit simple assault. He was sentenced to serve up to six years in prison.

He served the one-year minimum, then was ordered to serve three to six months in jail for violating a protection-from-abuse order involving his estranged wife in 2010, according to court records. He remains in prison on a parole detainer.

In the motion, Monroeville attorney Patrick J. Thomassey contends that Downs should get a new trial or be given an opportunity to appeal to Superior Court because his trial attorney, Thomas Shaffer, and his appellant counsel, Nicholas Timperio, were ineffective.

According to the motion, Downs lost his chance to appeal his conviction to Superior Court when Timperio missed a filing deadline by one day. Timperio, according to the brief, was awaiting a trial transcript as new counsel in the case and was denied an extension by Warman.

The motion challenges Shaffer's decision to call Darlene Reese as a witness during the trial. Reese's son threw the baseball that injured the other player, according to trial testimony.

When Reese did not testify that the ball's throwing was the result of a misunderstanding — as Shaffer wanted — the attorney attempted to call Eric Forsythe, president of the Robert W. Clark League, to impeach Reese's testimony, according to the motion.

Warman did not permit Clark's testimony for impeachment purposes.

“(Downs) contends that failure on the part of Shaffer to know what Mrs. Reese would testify to constitutes an unreasonable failure to prepare for trial and is thus, ineffectiveness, which acted to (Downs') prejudice,” Thomassey said in the motion. “Shaffer then compounded this error by attempting to impeach his own witness with testimony from Forsythe, which the court did not permit, leaving a negative impression on the jury and prejudicing them against his defense.”

Bob Stiles is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. He can be reached at 724-836-6622 or bstiles@tribweb.com.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Fayette

  1. Fayette County candy stores say public sweet on jelly beans as well as chocolate
  2. Connellsville’s new curfew —with stiffer penalties — to begin on April 26
  3. Connellsville not yet worried about possible CDBG cuts
  4. Brush fire season keeps Fayette firefighters busy
  5. Celebrate National Library Month with sweet contest in Connellsville
  6. No date set for closing on proposed hotel property in Connellsville
  7. Attorney says Fayette County officials’ policy on recording goes against state law
  8. Cause of Mill Run turbine collapse still being investigated
  9. Dunbar discusses renovation of town
  10. Fayette County residents driving force behind PAlitFest
  11. Resource fair planned for area veterans
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.