TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Humpty Dumpty over recess

About George F. Will

Daily Photo Galleries


By George F. Will

Published: Wednesday, Oct. 10, 2012, 9:00 p.m.

“The president shall have power to fill up all vacancies that may happen during the recess of the Senate.”

The Constitution, Article II, Section 2

' When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said in a rather scornful tone, ‘it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.'”

Lewis Carroll, “Through the Looking Glass”

WASHINGTON

When on Jan. 20, 2009, Barack Obama swore to defend the Constitution, he did not mean all of it. On Jan. 4, 2012, Obama simply ignored the Recess Clause. On that day, he used recess appointments to fill three seats on the National Labor Relations Board, even though the Senate said it was not in recess. Obama's cheeky Humpty Dumpty rejoinder was: I decide what “recess” means. Now a court must decide whether the Constitution means what it says.

In 2011, the Noel Canning company, which bottles soft drinks in Yakima, Wash., was negotiating a labor contract with Teamsters Local 760. The union says it and the company reached a verbal agreement. The company disagrees. An administrative law judge sided with the union. On Feb. 8, 2012, after Obama's disputed appointments, the NLRB upheld that decision and asked a federal court to enforce it. Noel Canning is asking the court to declare that the NLRB's intervention in the dispute was unlawful because the board lacked a quorum until Obama made the recess appointments, which were invalid because the Senate was not in recess.

The Recess Clause says the president's power extends only to vacancies that “happen” while the Senate is in recess. This does not describe the NLRB vacancies. The Framers wrote the Recess Clause to give presidents very limited authority to fill important posts, while preserving the Senate's absolute veto over presidential nominations.

For more than a century, it was generally accepted that recess appointments could only fill vacancies that occurred between sessions, not in recesses during sessions. Of late, however, presidents of both parties have made many recess appointments during short adjournments. To limit this, both parties when controlling Congress have adopted the practice of conducting pro forma sessions so the Senate is not in recess even while most senators are away.

It was holding such sessions every three days when Obama abandoned the settled policy of presidents respecting this practice. He treated the Senate's unwillingness to act on his NLRB nominations as an inability to act, and said this inability constituted a de facto recess. He disregarded the Senate's express determinations on Jan. 3 and 6 that it was in session.

Because the Constitution unambiguously gives the Senate the power to regulate its proceedings, Obama's opinion that the Senate was not in session when it said it was, and his assertion that it was in recess even though it held sessions on Jan. 3 and 6, has no force or relevance.

The constitutional guarantee of congressional self-governance, combined with the Senate's determination that it was in session Jan. 4, destroys Obama's position, which is that he can declare the Senate in recess whenever he wishes to exercise what the Framers explicitly denied to presidents — a unilateral appointments power. Consider this episode when deciding whether on Jan. 20, 2013, he should again have a chance to swear to (only selectively) defend the Constitution.

George F. Will is a columnist for The Washington Post and Newsweek.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. UPMC to city: Try to tax our subsidiaries
  2. Cueto gets best of Bucs, as Reds take series
  3. Obama hopes to replicate CCAC job training efforts across U.S.
  4. Connellsville area benefits from tourism grant program
  5. Starkey: Fleury’s future at stake
  6. Authorities plan to withdraw charge against bullied South Fayette student
  7. Police: Volunteer firefighter admits to setting fires
  8. Connellsville police hitting the streets on foot and bikes
  9. Jailed Hribal ‘fine,’ but family ‘terrible’ as answers in stabbing sought
  10. Five years later, Crosby wants another Cup win
  11. South Fayette parents express dissatisfaction with handling of bullying
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.