TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

City of Pittsburgh v. UPMC: Necessary lawsuits

Daily Photo Galleries

Thursday, March 21, 2013, 8:55 p.m.
 

UPMC was quick to spin the City of Pittsburgh's legal challenge of its tax-exempt status as a vendetta fueled by politicians doing the bidding of organized labor and business interests. It's a smokescreen, of course. And rationalizations of such grand conspiracies can't hide the fact the “nonprofit” claims of this $10 billion worldwide hospital behemoth are ripe for vetting in a court of law.

In separate legal actions on Wednesday, Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, who is not seeking re-election, filed suit to eliminate UPMC's city payroll tax exemption. A separate filing challenges the tax-exempt status of UPMC's 150 city properties. Those exemptions are valued at as much as $20 million annually for the city and $200 million annually statewide.

The profit-motive looms large at UPMC, the city claims, citing service reductions or closures in poorer neighborhoods, lavish executive salaries and perks and an ever-expanding worldwide footprint. The nub of the lawsuits' rub is that UPMC fails to meet the state's definition of a “purely public charity,” as defined in a 2012 state Supreme Court ruling.

UPMC, Pennsylvania's largest private employer, counters that its charitable giving and uncompensated care more than offset those tax bills. And even as a nonprofit, it must compete for revenues to enable it to serve its health-care mission, revenues that are reinvested in its operations, UPMC says.

Some will argue that the cost of these lawsuits, certain to be expensive, aren't worth it. But it's past time to settle a matter that's been festering for decades and to finally define what “nonprofit” and “charity” really mean.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Editorials

  1. Obama’s amnesty: Abuse of power
  2. Ford City’s police: A taxing question
  3. Saturday essay: Prelude to thanks
  4. Thanksgiving 2014: A season for giving
  5. The Kathleen Kane chronicles: The Pa. attorney general’s credibility is gone
  6. Saturday essay: Fallen leaves
  7. Greensburg Laurels & Lances
  8. Taxing policies
  9. Let there be lights: Bless nonprofit, everyone
  10. Connellsville roundtable: A good first step
  11. The Mitch Rubin sentence: Another wet noodle
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.