Our work ethic: A disturbing question
A new study showing that all U.S. employment gains since 2000 have benefited immigrants, legal and illegal, while native-born workers' employment has fallen undercuts the Senate-passed immigration bill's “the nation needs more workers” rationale — and begs a disturbing question about nonworking Americans.
Based on U.S. Census Bureau information, the Center for Immigration Studies ( cis.org) reports that 22.4 million immigrants of working age held jobs as 2013 began, up 5.3 million from the start of 2000. Meanwhile, jobs held by native-born workers dropped by 1.3 million and the ranks of Americans entirely out of the labor force grew by almost 13 million.
Conventional wisdom credits immigrants seeking a foothold toward achieving the American dream for willingness to work hard in menial, dirty, even dangerous jobs that the native-born don't want to do. The new CIS study suggests more Americans than ever see such jobs as beneath them, begging this question:
What's wrong with the American worker?
The likely answer: That “beneath me” attitude has become all the more prevalent among Americans as their government has reduced incentives to work, thereby increasing incentives to rely on taxpayer-funded entitlements.
America doesn't need more immigrant workers. It needs more Americans who are willing to work as hard as immigrants — and prefer individual initiative, self-reliance and holding any job over dependency on the public dole.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Mon-Yough Laurels & Lances
- Pittsburgh Laurels & Lances
- Greensburg Laurels & Lances
- Voter ID: A case reaffirmed
- Alle-Kiski Laurels & Lances
- Obama’s amnesty tab: Where credit isn’t due
- Nonprofit questions: Highmark’s future
- Saturday essay: Spring, slowly
- The truth behind H-1B
- Mon-Yough Tuesday takes
- Waterfront parent alert