Maglev: It's baaaaack
By The Tribune-Review
Published: Sunday, Nov. 24, 2013, 9:00 p.m.
Whatever the Japanese term for “boondoggle” is, it fits the latest attempt to bring to America magnetic levitation trains, which still make no financial or practical sense — even with, as The New York Times reports, Japan's government offering “to cover several billion dollars in costs.”
That offer — as bad a deal for Japanese taxpayers as maglev always has been for U.S. taxpayers — is an indication of Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's desperation to boost Japan's economy and high-tech standing. He's pitching a new maglev system that's reached a record 350 mph in tests but faces deep, familiar-sounding skepticism at home about cost and demand.
The Northeast Maglev, a Washington, D.C., company, wants to combine Mr. Abe's offer with public — U.S. taxpayers, beware! — and private funding for such a New York City-Washington maglev line. Its advisory board fittingly includes “Fast Eddie” — former Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell.
Abe has offered a free guideway and propulsion system between Washington and Baltimore — about 40 miles, too little distance for record speed to mean anything. And if the rest of the line isn't built — a likely scenario — that 40-mile stretch would be merely a curiosity.
There's a reason why Northeast Corridor high-speed train proposals, maglev or otherwise, have gone nowhere since Amtrak's 150-mph Acela debuted in 2000: They fail commonsense cost-benefit tests — even with a multibillion-dollar “sweetener” from Japan.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Hillary Clinton needs to answer for squandered aid money to Afghanistan’s corrupt war ministries
- Donor kidney discard rates: Unanswered questions
- The IRS scandal: The gun smokes
- Sunday pops
- Greensburg Tuesday takes
- Pittsburgh Tuesday takes
- The secret ballot: Protect it
- Junk nutrition
- Alle-Kiski Tuesday takes
- Alle-Kiski Laurels & Lances
- Lever A-1: Pot-infused brownies