TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

U.S. unprepared to patrol, secure vital Arctic region

Daily Photo Galleries

By Seth Andre Myers
Friday, Nov. 23, 2012, 8:57 p.m.
 

In the final presidential debate, when explaining why the Navy has fewer ships than in 1916, President Obama famously quipped that the United States also has "fewer horses and bayonets," setting off a debate over quality versus quantity.

In the Arctic - an increasingly important part of the world - the situation is simpler. When it comes to patrolling and securing the Arctic, the United States has neither quality nor quantity.

Melting Arctic sea ice is opening up previously unnavigable areas to shipping and drilling. Already, the maritime area in which the U.S. Coast Guard is responsible for safety, security and environmental protection missions is experiencing a significant increase in traffic.

To meet this challenge, the Coast Guard has three Arctic-capable icebreakers: two heavy-duty icebreakers - both of which were commissioned in the mid-1970s - and a more modern medium-duty icebreaker, the Healy. Were all three operational, the United States would lag behind several other Arctic nations in capabilities; in fact, only one, the Healy, is currently operational. According to a Coast Guard study, it will need at least six heavy-duty and four medium icebreakers just to meet mission requirements.

The 2013 fiscal-year budget includes money to begin the acquisition of one icebreaker, but it remains unpassed. With the threat of automatic spending cuts in early 2013 - and other cuts to the defense budget likely even if the so-called fiscal cliff is averted - there seems to be little appetite in Washington to invest in new and upgraded Arctic-capable systems.

Thus, for all the talk of projecting power abroad and ensuring the freedom of the seas, we are unable to effectively patrol the waters off our own territory, and this in an area whose importance is growing at a rate perhaps second only to that of the Asia-Pacific region.

In the meantime, other Arctic nations are taking the initiative. Norway, Canada and Russia have made developing both their military and civilian capabilities in the Arctic a priority.

The United States' lack of investment in the Arctic is not limited to the military. Obama routinely speaks of investing in America's infrastructure and rebuilding roads and rails. In most of north Alaska, there simply isn't much infrastructure to rebuild. It must, instead, be built in the first place.

The manner and extent to which we develop the Arctic remains, admittedly, undecided and controversial, especially with regard to the extraction of its natural resources. Amid significant opposition from environmental groups, Shell Oil has begun drilling offshore wells in the Alaskan Arctic, though setbacks have delayed completion of the wells until the summer of 2013 at the earliest.

The reality is that the Arctic is increasingly busy. Cruise ships are already operating in the region; it is only a matter of time before freight and tanker shipping follows.

From the original purchase of Alaska being derided as "Seward's Folly," the United States has long had an ambivalent relationship with the Arctic. But there probably will come a point when it will be forced to reckon with its role as an Arctic nation, whether or not we are prepared. We would do well to invest in our capabilities there now, lest we find ourselves reliant on little more than sled dogs and ice picks.

Seth Andre Myers is a research associate in the national security studies program of the Council on Foreign Relations.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Mental health facility won’t take Franklin Regional stabbing suspect as patient
  2. Steelers are vowing to fix the costly penalties, lack of self-discipline
  3. At least $100,000 in appliances stolen from new homes around Western Pa.
  4. Body found in Allegheny River near Clemente Bridge
  5. Steelers film session: Harrison on the field often
  6. Crafton men attacked in their home
  7. Gunfire plagues New Kensington
  8. Mon Valley bridges moved up to rapid replacement list
  9. 20 improbable Pirates wins in 2014
  10. Healthy again, Penguins’ Dupuis eager for game action
  11. Fundraising under way for Indiana County newborn struck by stray bullet
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.