TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

The great secession debate

Daily Photo Galleries

By Walter Williams
Saturday, Dec. 1, 2012, 9:02 p.m.
 

For decades, it has been obvious that there are irreconcilable differences between Americans who want to control the lives of others and those who wish to be left alone. Which is the more peaceful solution: Americans using the brute force of government to beat liberty-minded people into submission or simply parting company?

In a marriage, where vows are ignored and broken, divorce is the most peaceful solution. Similarly, our constitutional and human rights have been increasingly violated by a government instituted to protect them. Americans who support constitutional abrogation have no intention of mending their ways.

Since Barack Obama's re-election, hundreds of thousands of petitions for secession have reached the White House. Some people have argued that secession is unconstitutional. But there's absolutely nothing in the Constitution that prohibits it. What stops secession is the prospect of brute force by a mighty federal government, as witnessed by the costly War of 1861.

At the 1787 constitutional convention, a proposal was made to allow the federal government to suppress a seceding state. James Madison, the acknowledged father of our Constitution, rejected it, saying: “A Union of the States containing such an ingredient seemed to provide for its own destruction. The use of force against a State would look more like a declaration of war than an infliction of punishment and would probably be considered by the party attacked as a dissolution of all previous compacts by which it might be bound.”

On the eve of the War of 1861, even unionist politicians saw secession as a right of states. Rep. Jacob M. Kunkel of Maryland said, “Any attempt to preserve the Union between the States of this Confederacy by force would be impractical, and destructive of republican liberty.”

The Northern Democratic and Republican parties favored allowing the South to secede in peace. Just about every major Northern newspaper editorialized in favor of the South's right to secede.

There's more evidence seen at the time our Constitution was ratified. The ratification documents of Virginia, New York and Rhode Island explicitly said that they held the right to resume powers delegated, should the federal government become abusive of those powers. The Constitution would have never been ratified if states thought that they could not maintain their sovereignty.

The War of 1861 settled the issue of secession through brute force that cost 600,000 American lives. Americans celebrate Abraham Lincoln's Gettysburg Address, but H.L. Mencken correctly evaluated the speech, “It is poetry, not logic; beauty, not sense.” Lincoln said that the soldiers sacrificed their lives “to the cause of self-determination — that government of the people, by the people, for the people should not perish from the earth.” Mencken says: “It is difficult to imagine anything more untrue. The Union soldiers in the battle actually fought against self-determination; it was the Confederates who fought for the right of people to govern themselves.”

Walter Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Chryst returns home, named football coach at Wisconsin
  2. Pederson ousted as Pitt athletic director
  3. Pitt uses 2 2nd-half flurries to hold off Manhattan, 65-56
  4. NFL notebook: Bears bench QB Cutler, turn to Clausen
  5. Steelers notebook: Brown leads WRs in Pro Bowl voting, Bell 2nd at RB
  6. Carnegie man involved in police chase sues Pittsburgh and Homestead
  7. Penguins notebook: Kunitz tests foot by skating during practice
  8. Son charged in dismemberment death of Penn Hills couple
  9. With 3 more players possibly affected, Pens’ mumps fight escalates
  10. Parent finds body in parking lot of Stanton Heights elementary school, prompting lockdown
  11. Stock market jumps as Fed pledges patience in rate hikes
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.