One step in the right direction
Michigan is the 24th state to pass a right-to-work law, keeping workers from having to join a labor union or pay union dues in order to work in unionized businesses. This is a step in the direction of economic freedom, a competitive labor market and a pro-growth policy agenda.
The rationale for right-to-work laws is not grounded in ideological opposition to unions; nothing in right-to-work laws prevents workers from joining unions or keeps unions from bargaining collectively. These laws merely reflect the reality that states with right-to-work laws have more robust personal income growth, lower unemployment and greater opportunities for younger workers.
It's perfectly sensible that states that want to see their economies grow should enact right-to-work laws. But the privilege of unions to extract money from workers' paychecks is far from the only special preference granted by state policy.
Our economy is chock full of similar legal preferences that benefit particular entrenched interests, from unions to politically-connected operators. Too frequently, state-level policy does more to reward political connection and support special interests than encourage a real culture of competition.
Take the corporate welfare that too many states hand out under the guise of being “pro-business.”
According to a recent analysis by The New York Times, states provide more than $80 billion a year in so-called “business incentives.” The great majority of these are simply giveaways to political allies or favored economic sectors.
At the federal level, almost $100 billion is given away annually in corporate welfare, according to a study by Cato Institute analyst Tad DeHaven — and that doesn't include many Obama administration policies, such as the auto bailout. This represents an egregious affront to competitive, free markets.
Consider two other widespread instances of government policies that benefit small groups at the expense of consumers, workers and taxpayers: occupational licensing laws and anti-competitive education policies.
A recent study by the Institute for Justice, a public-interest law firm, finds that in the 1950s, one in 20 U.S. workers was subject to occupational licensing requirements, a figure that today stands at almost one in three.
Likewise, our education system has for too long been protected against meaningful competition.
As my American Enterprise Institute colleague Rick Hess has written about extensively, our school systems can be actively hostile to the educational entrepreneurship that develops and executes new forms of school organization and teaching. Far too much state education policy erects barriers to educational innovation, particularly with respect to the for-profit sector, rather than encouraging and embracing it.
In the economy and elsewhere, lawmakers should think about how to remove barriers to competition rather than try to pick winners to subsidize. They should simplify tax codes and regulation rather than creating special exemptions and loopholes. They should make it easier, not harder, for entrepreneurs to start and expand businesses and create jobs.
Right-to-work laws are an important step to bringing competition to labor markets and creating more growth and economic opportunity. But they are only part of the answer.
Arthur C. Brooks is president of the American Enterprise Institute (aei.org) and author of “The Road To Freedom” (Basic Books).
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Arrest made in June homicide in Hill District
- Court validates Highmark Medicare plan that excludes UPMC
- Ramps reopen from East Ohio and Heinz streets to northbound Route 28
- Steelers’ prime-time games shrink attendance at Heinz Field
- City Theatre hires James McNeel as new managing director
- State trooper struck by SUV in Westmoreland faces more surgery, long recovery
- Analyst outlines Klein’s supplements, prescriptions
- Woman’s body found in Adams home
- Menino, Boston’s longest-serving mayor, dies at 71
- Starkey: Hockey hypocrites, unite
- Kiski Valley-based ring charged with hundreds of thefts over 10 communities