| Opinion/The Review

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Brace yourself, Pennsylvania families

Letters home ...

Traveling abroad for personal, educational or professional reasons?

Why not share your impressions — and those of residents of foreign countries about the United States — with Trib readers in 150 words?

The world's a big place. Bring it home with Letters Home.

Contact Colin McNickle (412-320-7836 or

Daily Photo Galleries

By Nathan A. Benefield
Saturday, Jan. 26, 2013, 9:00 p.m.

Are you ready to pay an additional $1,000 in state and local taxes alone?

Prepared to see your child's teacher laid off?

Thanks to bad promises politicians made to good people, a pension crisis facing Pennsylvania threatens our American way of life, homes, cities and schools.

Nearly 6,000 classroom teachers in Pennsylvania public schools received pink slips over the past two school years. This unprecedented trend, following years in staff growth, will likely worsen due to skyrocketing pension costs with no financial safety net built in to protect good teachers.

What's more, homeowners will get socked with the pension bomb, too — for benefits that were promised by politicians but never paid for. School districts' pension payments (which cover only half the required payments) will rise substantially over the next four years. For school districts across the state, that cost increase comes to approximately $346 per homeowner.

But those local cost increases will vary by district — from as low as $102 in Schuylkill County's St. Clair Area district to $882 per homeowner in the Reading City School District.

As scary as that seems, it is but the tip of this woeful economic iceberg. State government's pension costs (for state employees and half of school employees' pensions) are expected to rise by more than $2.5 billion over the next four years — or $523 annually per household.

That is, many families will pay more than $1,000 in additional taxes for pension debt we accumulated over the past decade and get nothing more for their money.

So how did we get into this mess? Very simply, it is the culmination of a series of bad politics and policy decisions.

In 2001, following an economic boom, politicians thought pensions were well funded and stock market gains would continue indefinitely, so they decided to boost pension benefits for themselves and government workers, even doing so retroactively. When the stock market dropped, lawmakers erred again by voting to put off paying for those losses for years.

Those bills are now coming due, exacerbated by the big investment losses in 2008. But one can understand why lawmakers made the choices they did: There's a big political payoff for boosting benefits, as government unions lobbied heavily for those changes.

And there's little downside to delaying payments (with government unions lobbying for those changes, too). Those costs will be paid through generational theft, foisted upon our children and grandchildren, who are still too young to vote.

Ultimately, the only solution is to get politics out of pensions. This can only happen by moving from traditional pensions — where taxpayers provide a guaranteed government income for life — to a retirement plan popular in the private sector, similar to a 401(k).

In a 401(k), which most private companies switched to decades ago, lawmakers can't play politics. If they promise to contribute 6 percent of salary, they must put that in and can't defer those costs to our kids and grandkids. Further, 401(k)-style plans are predictable for elected officials, allowing them to plan for all costs and avoid massive property tax hikes. And they're affordable for taxpayers.

Moreover, 401(k) plans offer more convenience for workers. Younger workers especially will benefit from the ability to take 401(k)s with them as they change jobs instead of forfeiting retirement savings to advance their careers.

Older adults can pass their remaining 401(k)s on to their children, whereas pension payouts end when retirees die, even if they paid in more than they collected. And all workers will benefit from a sustainable retirement system that will actually be there when they retire.

Legislation sponsored by Sen. Pat Browne (R-Lehigh County) last session would place all new state and school employees in a 401(k)-style retirement plan. As they say, “When you're in a hole, stop digging,” and this legislation would stop digging a deeper pension hole and empower new government employees to have ownership over their retirement.

However, this reform doesn't pay off the pension shortfall we've already built up by overpromising pensions. These costs will continue to burden state taxpayers, schools and local governments for years.

Lawmakers must recognize the effect the pension bomb will have on Pennsylvania and show courage to defuse it before the fallout reaches our already stressed families. They must resist the urge to repeat the spending splurge of years past, create new programs or throw money at problems.

Moreover, to find money for pensions without raising taxes on working families, lawmakers must find significant savings through prevailing wage reform, ending corporate welfare and tackling bloated and wasteful welfare spending.

Today, the pension bomb facing Pennsylvania threatens homeowners with massive tax hikes and schoolteachers and other government workers with layoffs. If our children and grandchildren are to have a prosperous tomorrow, they can't afford any more missteps from their leaders. Defusing the pension bomb, for their sake, must be job No. 1 for state lawmakers this year.

Nathan A. Benefield is director of policy analysis with the Commonwealth Foundation (

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Penguins need trade-deadline acquisitions to bring toughness
  2. Blue Jays’ Martin has ‘nothing but praise’ for former Pirates teammates
  3. Panthers still clinging to hope entering home finale
  4. Gorman: Indiana has its ‘Hoosiers’
  5. 10th DUI earns Uptown man 1st prison sentence
  6. Southmoreland, Mt. Pleasant wrestlers look forward to states
  7. Mt. Lebanon senior Stout has legacy that links to Kurt Angle
  8. Pitt’s Wright excelling in classroom
  9. Burrell’s Beattie taking final shot at PIAA title
  10. Pittsburgh Tribune-Review athletes of the week: South Fayette’s Mike Carr, Blackhawk’s Courtney Vannoy
  11. Safety Vinopal, other former Panthers perform for NFL scouts at Pitt’s Pro Day