Waste more, want more
President Obama has new priorities. That means new spending.
In his State of the Union address, he said, “The American people don't expect government to solve every problem.” Then he went on to list how, under his guidance, government will solve a thousand problems, including some (like climate change and a loss of manufacturing jobs) that are probably not even problems.
The president bragged about creating “our first manufacturing innovation institute” in Ohio and says that he will create 15 more. Politicians claim actions like this are needed to solve the “decline of manufacturing” in America. But what they call “decline” is myth. There is no decline in manufacturing.
The Federal Reserve says U.S. manufacturing output is up from 2000, and up almost 50 percent from 1990. Yes, manufacturing employment is down because automation and government's labor rules led companies to automate and produce more with fewer employees, but that's OK.
When the need for people in one type of industry decreases — say, making wagon wheels — they are freed up to work in other areas. What America needs is a flexible economy that provides new jobs. For years, we had that.
Workers who lost factory jobs found new work in the fast-growing service industry. Creating software, movies and medical innovation is just as valuable as manufacturing and often more comfortable for workers.
“Yet the president wants 15 ‘manufacturing hubs,' which I guess will be like Solyndra cities,” lamented Deroy Murdock, one of three libertarian reporters who came on my show to react to our president's plans.
This month, the Energy Department's inspector general reports that, three years after being awarded a $150 million federal grant, a taxpayer-backed battery plant in Holland, Mich., has not produced a single battery. At one point, the company's workers were paid to do nothing.
Then came the president's call for more spending on preschool.
“I am sympathetic to people wanting to shove their kids out the door,” joked Katherine Mangu-Ward of Reason magazine, “but Head Start, our pilot program for universal preschool, has a not-great record. We spend $8 billion to get very, very little in terms of results. ... We suck at education.”
Well, government does.
Journalist Michael C. Moynihan was disappointed that President Obama's speech contained no talk of significant reform of Social Security and Medicare. “Even in this sort of dire circumstance: no change whatsoever.”
Both parties are guilty of avoiding our “dire circumstance,” said Moynihan. “There was a big announcement in 2011 — $300, $400 billion in spending would be cut, (but) this was a mirage, there were no spending cuts. ... (What) cuts in Washington mean is that you reduce the rate of increase a little.”
Instead of letting obsolete government programs die, bureaucrats come up with new excuses to keep spending. “Like the Rural Electrification Administration,” said Murdock. “That was put in by FDR to bring power to Appalachia. (Now) they put in broadband Internet.”
So America continues to move toward bankruptcy. Instead of addressing that, the politicians will spend more. Instead of announcing 15 new “manufacturing” hubs, the president should just announce 300 million “do whatever you want with your own money” hubs. Then American citizens can do as they please.
John Stossel is host of “Stossel” on the Fox Business Network. He's the author of “No They Can't: Why Government Fails, but Individuals Succeed.”
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Jerome Bettis to be enshrined in hall of fame
- Rossi: History beckons for Seattle’s Seahawks
- Suggestions are aplenty on what Penguins need to break through
- January temperatures, snowfall unremarkable in Western Pennsylvania
- Springdale trestle bridge deemed structurally sound
- CMU software eases task of mining prostitution ads
- Westmoreland museum spotlights artist John Kane’s late-in-life fame
- Tennessee quarterback Peterman considers transfer to Pitt
- New Kensington woman struck by vehicle, injured
- Alle-Kiski Valley deemed medically underserved
- Familiar Downtown Pittsburgh presence lost arm, leg to train