There's more that binds than divides GOP
“At CPAC, the Future Looks Libertarian,” read a dispatch on Time magazine's website. “CPAC: Rand Paul's Big Moment,” proclaimed The Week magazine. Meanwhile, The New York Times headlined its story about the annual conservative political-action conference “GOP divisions fester at conservative retreat.”
George Will, a man who actually knows a thing or two about conservatism, responded to The Times' use of the word “fester” on ABC News' “This Week.” “Festering: an infected wound, it's awful. I guarantee you, if there were a liberal conclave comparable to this, and there were vigorous debates going on there, The New York Times' headline would be ‘Healthy diversity flourishes at the liberal conclave.'”
Will went on to note that social conservatives and libertarian free-market conservatives in the GOP have been arguing “since the 1950s, when the National Review was founded on the idea of the fusion of the two. It has worked before with Ronald Reagan. It can work again.”
Will was right as far as he went, but I would go further. Fusionism was an idea hatched by Frank Meyer, a brilliant intellectual and editor at National Review. An ex-communist Christian libertarian, Meyer argued that freedom was a prerequisite for virtue and therefore a virtuous society must be a free society. (If I force you to do the right thing against your will, you cannot claim to have acted virtuously.)
Philosophically, the idea took fire from all sides. But as a uniting principle, fusionism worked well. It provided a rationale for most libertarians and most social conservatives to fight side by side against communism abroad and big government at home.
What often gets left out in discussions of the American right is that fusionism isn't merely an alliance; it is an alloy. Fusionism runs through the conservative heart.
William F. Buckley, the founder of the conservative movement, often called himself a “libertarian journalist.” Asked about that in a 1993 interview, he told C-SPAN's Brian Lamb that the question “Does this augment or diminish human liberty?” informed most of what he wrote.
Just look at where libertarianism has had its greatest impact: economics. There simply isn't a conservative economics that is distinct from a libertarian one.
Libertarian and conservative critiques of ObamaCare, the stimulus and other Democrat policies are indistinguishable from one another. On trade, taxes, property rights, energy, the environment, intellectual property and other issues, I'd be hard-pressed to tell you the difference, if any, between the conservative and libertarian positions.
On the Constitution, there are some interesting debates, but both factions are united in rejecting a “living Constitution.” The debate on the right is over what the Constitution says, not what liberals think it should say.
Sen. Rand Paul, R-Ky., according to most media accounts, represents a new, younger, more libertarian approach. But at CPAC, Paul also announced that he would be introducing the “Life at Conception Act.” On gay marriage, Paul's position is that it should be left to the states.
Libertarianism has a better brand name than conservatism these days, particularly among young people. Conservatives shouldn't be freaking out about this any more than libertarians should start a victory dance. The agreements between the two sides remain far greater than the differences.
Jonah Goldberg is the author of the new book “The Tyranny of Clichés.”
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Shareholder vote causes ATI to review executive pay packages
- Lowly job likely awaits former Pittsburgh police chief after prison
- Cole outduels Mets rookie, carries Pirates to victory
- Islamic State claims suicide blast in Saudi mosque
- King gets surprise Late Model victory at Lernerville
- ‘Dope sick’ man in custody in Mt. Pleasant stick-up
- Gorman: Obama Academy boys volleyball leads way for City League in WPIAL
- Monessen man faces trial in shooting
- Fox Chapel, Ambridge capture WPIAL volleyball titles
- Hempfield pair caught in vehicle scam
- Dunbar Township MedExpress plans open house for Tuesday