TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

In Israel, no silver linings

Letters home ...

Traveling abroad for personal, educational or professional reasons?

Why not share your impressions — and those of residents of foreign countries about the United States — with Trib readers in 150 words?

The world's a big place. Bring it home with Letters Home.

Contact Colin McNickle (412-320-7836 or cmcnickle@tribweb.com).

Daily Photo Galleries

By Michael Gerson
Wednesday, July 17, 2013, 9:00 p.m.
 

THE GOLAN HEIGHTS

The abandoned Circassian village of Zureiman provides a vantage point across the fortified Israeli border into Syria. Regime forces hold an area from the crossing at Quneitra to Runheineh. Elements of the rebel Free Syrian Army are attacking from both north and south, attempting to close the corridor. Farther south in Syria, global jihadist groups predominate.

A few miles back from the border, traveling between minefields that cover 30 percent of the Golan, you come to an Israeli winery serving samples and lunch. It smacks of symbolism: ten minutes from the Syrian civil war to a nice sauvignon blanc.

Israel is the relatively quiet eye of the Middle Eastern storm. But there are vistas of conflict on nearly every side. The triumph of Bashar al-Assad in Syria, according to Sallai Meridor, the former Israeli ambassador to the United States, would “not be the devil we know, but a much worse devil, an agent of Iran and Hezbollah.” Israel's cold peace with Egypt is fragile, and a distracted Egyptian military could allow jihadists to cause trouble in the Sinai. “We look at Jordan,” says Meridor, “and pray.”

Not all the consequences of regional chaos are immediately bad for Israel. The Syrian military has been decimated as a fighting force. Hezbollah, by joining Assad's anti-Sunni holy war, has lost its luster in the Arab world.

But the general Israeli attitude is worry and wariness. “Everything looks worse,” says Meridor. “There is a feeling that we can be prepared, but there is nothing proactive we can do about it.” So Israeli foreign policy focuses on disrupting short-term threats (such as arms transfers to Hezbollah) rather than developing long-term strategies. And Israeli politics has turned inward toward domestic concerns.

Many Israeli political figures share a concern that America has also become reactive, that it is focused on disrupting short-term threats rather than developing long-term strategies and that American politics has turned inward toward domestic concerns.

In the most favorable interpretation, America is rebalancing burdens between a reluctant superpower and free-riding allies, or pivoting to Asia. But America is accompanying this shift with an impression of political paralysis, rising debt and growing public skepticism about global engagement.

American passivity and confusion have left a trail of missed opportunities. During the Iranian Green Revolution of 2009, the administration remained fixed on a strategy of regime engagement. In 2011, it hesitated in supporting Syria's civil uprising. Since 2011, it managed to convince every side in Egypt that America has betrayed them.

A regional power such as Israel may be able to afford a reactive, short-term approach. If America does not proactively shape the security environments in which it operates, it is left to respond on progressively less favorable terms. The collapse of, say, Jordan, or the collapse of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty system would have profound implications for American security.

America, of course, is not abandoning the Middle East, just creating an impression of tired ambivalence. Nearly every Israeli politician, legislator and think-tank scholar seems to be debating if America has really drawn a red line on Iranian nuclear weapons or is leaving some strategic ambiguity.

Such debates, conducted over a glass of wine, eventually become less theoretical, as the storm gathers strength.

Michael Gerson is a columnist for The Washington Post.

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Bomb plot trial ends in Saudi’s conviction
  2. Trade for Winnik gives Penguins’ competition among bottom six
  3. Sophomore stars carry Beaver Falls to 3rd finals appearance in 4 seasons
  4. High school notebook: Armstrong, Freeport know playoff opponents
  5. Trib Cup: South Park girls look ahead to PIAA tournament
  6. Lincoln tries to rejuvenate career in second stint with Pirates
  7. Few in Westmoreland County opposed to expansion plan for Mariner pipeline
  8. Move to Canon-McMillan means less travel for wrestlers headed to Southwest Regional
  9. High school roundup: Mt. Lebanon boys oust Hempfield
  10. Jihadi John, slashing terrorist, is unmasked as Briton
  11. Notre Dame women shoot lights out in victory over Pitt