The toll of isolation
In the 20th century, Western intellectuals' two most dominant explanations of disparities in economic, education and other achievements were innate racial differences in ability (in the early decades) and racial discrimination (in the later decades).
In neither era were the intelligentsia receptive to other explanations. In each era, they were convinced that they had the answer — and dismissed and disparaged those who offered other answers.
Differences in mental test scores among different racial and ethnic groups were taken as proof of genetic differences in innate mental ability during the Progressive era in the early 20th century. Progressives regarded the fact that the average IQ test score among whites was higher than the average among blacks as conclusive proof of genetic determinism.
A closer look at mental test data, however, shows that there were not only individual blacks with higher IQs than most whites, but also whole categories of whites who scored at or below the mental test scores of blacks.
Among American soldiers given mental tests during World War I, for example, white soldiers from Georgia, Arkansas, Kentucky and Mississippi scored lower than black soldiers from Ohio, Illinois, New York and Pennsylvania.
Looking at achievements in general, people living in geographically isolated environments around the world have long lagged behind the progress of people with a wider cultural universe, regardless of the race of the people in these isolated places. When the Spaniards discovered the Canary Islands in the 15th century, they found people of a Caucasian race living at a Stone Age level.
Many mountain communities around the world also have been isolated, especially during the centuries before modern transportation and communications. These mountain communities were not only isolated from the outside world but also from each other, even when they were not very far apart as the crow flies.
As distinguished French historian Fernand Braudel put it, “Mountain life persistently lagged behind the plain.” A pattern of poverty and backwardness could be found from the Appalachian Mountains in the United States to the Rif Mountains of Morocco.
Cultural isolation because of geographic factors afflicts not only people isolated in mountains or on islands far from the nearest mainland, but also people isolated by deserts or in places isolated by a lack of navigable waterways — or even by a lack of animal transport, as was the situation in the Western Hemisphere when Europeans arrived and brought horses that were unknown to the indigenous people.
Cultural isolation also can be due to government decisions, as when the governments of 15th-century China and 17th-century Japan deliberately isolated their respective people from the outside world. At that time, China was the leading nation in the world. But it lost that lead during centuries of isolation.
Against this background, racial and ethnic leaders around the world who promote a separate cultural “identity” are inflicting a handicap on their own people.
Isolation has held back many people in many lands — for centuries. But such social and cultural isolation serves the interests of today's ethnic leaders.
They have every incentive to promote a breast-beating isolation. It is a sweet-tasting poison.
Thomas Sowell is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Steelers QB Roethlisberger not targeting Oct. 25 return
- $11M gift from Hillman to help CMU attract faculty, support students
- Keuchel, Astros beat Yankees
- Plum school board asks why tip line was removed from student handbook
- Steelers notebook: Tomlin not worried about Jones’ lack of sacks
- New Florence assistant fire chief charged with having sex with juvenile
- Pitt women’s soccer makes history; West Virginia doesn’t want to repeat it
- Audit: Work of adviser in Pa. Department of Education hard to pin down
- Rossi: Time for Pirates to take next step
- Former Mich. lawmaker uses D.C. trip to lobby for better veterans health care
- Ligonier council approves design changes to Diamond