TribLIVE

| Opinion/The Review


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Let the Ex-Im Bank fail

Daily Photo Galleries

By William F. Shughart Ii
Monday, June 23, 2014, 9:00 p.m.
 

Neither you nor I can open an account at the Export-Import Bank in Washington, but major U.S. exporters and foreign buyers of those exports can and have. The list of the bank's largest clients includes global business behemoths like Boeing, John Deere, Ford Motor Co. and Merck (in pharmaceuticals) and Bechtel (in engineering). China, Saudi Arabia and other destinations of American exports also are on the list.

A legacy of FDR's New Deal, the Ex-Im Bank was created at a time when the Great Depression and protectionist international trade regulations (the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930 is the chief culprit) had caused American exports to shrink dramatically. Agriculture was hit particularly hard by that manmade economic disaster. The Ex-Im Bank was supposed to help prop up domestic farm prices by subsidizing agricultural exports to Europe and other overseas markets.

Fast-forward to 2014, when Congress will consider legislation to “reauthorize” the bank's charter, which expires on Sept. 30. Last year, the Ex-Im extended roughly $27 billion in loans, loan guarantees and credit insurance to both domestic and foreign companies in order to promote exports of American goods overseas, bringing the bank's total contingent liabilities to about $140 billion.

The Ex-Im Bank supplies credit to U.S. companies to “facilitate” exports by guaranteeing any loans exporters offer to purchasers in foreign nations buying American goods. Because every dollar of the money obligated by the Ex-Im Bank is backed by the “full faith and credit” of the federal government, the overburdened American taxpayer is on the hook if any borrower fails to repay.

Boeing — one of only two assemblers of long-distance commercial aircraft in the world — hardly needs a U.S. government guarantee to sell its planes to China, Saudi Arabia and elsewhere. Nor do the state-owned airlines in those nations need such guarantees to buy them. True, Boeing's main competitor, Airbus, is a government-financed enterprise, but because European taxpayers bankroll Airbus is no reason for the United States to bankroll Boeing.

Somewhat ironically, the Ex-Im Bank's reauthorization may be in trouble not from opposition by taxpayers or some economists, but because of labor unions' resistance.

A recent editorial in the Detroit News reports that miners and the companies that employ them in Michigan's Upper Peninsula are outraged by a loan to an Australian iron ore producer to subsidize the purchase of equipment because it threatens a shift of mining jobs to the Antipodes. Delta Airlines and the American Pilots Association also have sued the Ex-Im Bank for granting guaranteed, low-interest loans to foreign airlines, which give them a competitive advantage over U.S. air carriers.

It is a truism of international economic theory that “imports pay for exports.” When Americans buy goods from suppliers overseas, those suppliers in turn earn dollars that can be used to purchase goods manufactured in the United States.

Any public policy that interferes with the free flow of international commerce (whether it subsidizes exports or penalizes imports) makes the world poorer.

William F. Shughart II, a research director and senior fellow of The Independent Institute, is a professor in public choice at Utah State University.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. New movie studio coming to McKees Rocks
  2. Ex-judge in Philadelphia charged with bribery, conspiracy in sting case
  3. Bell Acres police investigate attempted child luring
  4. Allegheny County D.A.’s office rounding up drug suspects
  5. One Direction bring 2015 stadium tour to Heinz Field
  6. Starkey: Century mark beckons for Ben
  7. Steelers’ defense on pace for fewest sacks in 16-game season
  8. Study: Renewables as green as you’d expect
  9. Flyers continue mastery of Penguins at Consol
  10. Finnbogi Petursson’s ‘Second/Second’ addresses the connection of water, sound, frequency
  11. Judge orders W.Va. agency to release pollution data
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.