Mountain out of a molehill
By George F. Will
Published: Wednesday, December 19, 2012, 8:50 p.m.
Updated: Tuesday, February 19, 2013
The poet Carl Sandburg supposedly was asked by a young playwright to attend a rehearsal. Sandburg did but fell asleep. The playwright exclaimed, “How could you sleep when you knew I wanted your opinion?” Sandburg replied, “Sleep is an opinion.”
So is nonvoting. Remember this as the Obama administration mounts a drive to federalize voter registration, a step toward making voting mandatory.
Attorney General Eric Holder considers it alarming that 60 million adult citizens were not registered in 2008. He wants Washington to register everyone automatically. But the fact many people do not register to vote is not evidence that the franchise is restricted other than by voters' inertia.
Assistant Attorney General Thomas Perez, head of Holder's civil rights division, rightly says that voting too often is “an endurance contest” involving a long wait in line, frequently because of questions about voters' registrations.
But The Heritage Foundation's Hans von Spakovsky, a former member of the Federal Election Commission, says: “One of the reasons that state voter registration rolls are in such poor shape today — with large numbers of voters who are dead, have moved or are noncitizens — is because of the restrictive standards imposed by the federal government in 1993 by the National Voter Registration Act. That law made it very difficult to remove ineligible voters. Local jurisdictions were sued so often by the Justice Department when they tried to remove ineligible voters, many stopped trying to clean up their lists at all.”
Notice the perverse dialectic by which Washington aggrandizes its power: It promises to ameliorate problems exacerbated by its supposedly ameliorative policies. Liberals love mandates (e.g., health insurance). Why not mandatory voting?
In 1960, 62.8 percent of age-eligible citizens voted. In the 13 subsequent presidential elections, lower turnouts than this have coincided with the removal of impediments to voting (poll taxes, literacy tests, burdensome registration and residency requirements). Turnout has not increased as the electorate has become more educated and affluent and as government has become more involved in Americans' lives. There are four obvious reasons for nonvoting.
One is contentment. Americans are voluble complainers but are mostly comfortable. Second, the stakes of politics are agreeably low because constitutional rights and other essential elements of happiness are not menaced by elections.
Third, the winner-take-all allocation of electoral votes in 48 states — an excellent idea, for many reasons — means many state races are without suspense. Fourth, gerrymandered federal and state legislative districts reduce competitive races.
Because the likelihood of any individual's vote mattering is infinitesimal, and because the effort required to be an informed voter can be substantial, ignorance and abstention are rational, unless voting is cathartic or otherwise satisfying. A small voting requirement such as registration acts to filter potential voters with the weakest motivations. As indifferent or reluctant voters are nagged to the polls — or someday prodded there by a monetary penalty for nonvoting — the caliber of the electorate must decline.
It has been said that for every complex problem there is a solution that is clear, simple and wrong. Washington soon may seek a complex “solution” — pre-emption of states' responsibilities; federal micromanagement of elections; eventual coercion of lackadaisical citizens — to the nonproblem of people choosing not to vote.
George F. Will is a columnist for The Washington Post and Newsweek.
- Pirates beat Cubs, 4-2, to finish homestand with sweep
- Pens will unveil even bigger TV screen for fans in Game 5
- Penguins notebook: Bylsma likes response to adversity
- Senators notebook: Anderson will remain in goal
- Whitehall couple sues Pittsburgh zoo over son’s mauling by painted dogs
- Steelers notebook: Slimmed-down Redman optimistic for 2013
- Pitt baseball loses, has tough road to Big East final
- Steelers veteran outside linebacker Woodley: ‘I’m good to go’
- Fayette County casino to open July 1
- Neal, Iginla get back on track to lead Penguins
- Kovacevic: It’s about time for these Penguins
You must be signed in to add comments
To comment, click the Sign in or sign up at the very top of this page.
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.