| Sports

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Deep QB class proves tempting to NFL general managers

Steelers/NFL Videos

Scouting the quarterbacks

1. Johnny Manziel

Texas A&M, 5-111⁄2, 207

Certifiable winner, leader, extremely productive (7,820 yards passing and 63 TD passes in two seasons) and the first freshman to win the Heisman Trophy. Downside: Lack of size, tendency to abandon the pocket, potential durability issues. But his competitiveness is incontestable, and so is his ability to win. Loves the big stage, and no stage is bigger than the NFL. And Russell Wilson has proven a QB of his size can excel.

2. Blake Bortles

Central Florida, 6-5, 232

Roethlisberger-sized, he threw for 56 TDs and ran for 15 more in '13. Hard worker and coachable. Excellent in the pocket. But competition wasn't top-echelon, and neither is his ability to read defenses and throw downfield consistently.

3. Derek Carr

Fresno State, 6-2, 214

Best-in-class numbers: 87 TDs, 9,187 yards and only 15 INTs in last two seasons. Threw 306 consecutive passes without an INT. School-record 12,843 yards. Matthew Stafford-like, but some teams might be scared off because brother David was a bust as No. 1 overall pick.

4. Teddy Bridgewater

Louisville, 6-2, 214

Good arm, can extend the pocket and his stats are exceptional: 7,688 yards, 58 TDs, 12 INTs last two seasons. But he's slender and probably won't gain much more weight, and there are questions about long-term durability. Small hands also concern some teams.

5. A.J. McCarron

Alabama, 6-2, 220

He's far down some analysts' lists, partly because Alabama QBs often struggle in NFL. But he's an exceptional leader with huge stats (more than 6,000 yards the last two seasons in elite SEC), makes all the throws and is a proven winner. Might be most underrated player in draft.

6. Zach Mettenberger

LSU, 6-41⁄2, 224

Like Bortles, more of a classic, drop-back style QB with a very strong arm who can make any throw. Threw for 5,601 yards last two seasons. But there are injury (ACL) and character issues; he was thrown off Georgia's team following a March 2010 arrest. And he struggles at times while under pressure.

7. Jimmy Garappolo

Eastern Illinois, 6-2, 226

Broke most of Tony Romo's school records, throwing for 13,156 yards and 118 TDs. Lively arm. Won the 2013 Walter Payton Award in FCS but sometimes lacks velocity. Played in spread offense, so must get comfortable taking snaps under center.

8. Tom Savage

Pitt, 6-31⁄2, 228

Late riser on draft charts who could go early in second round. Teams like his above-average arm strength, velocity and toughness (was most-sacked QB in Division I with 43). Can be streaky, but tall, old-school-type dropback passers with leadership skills are always in demand.

9. Keith Wenning

Ball State, 6-21⁄2, 218

Could be a mid-round gamble who pays off big for a patient team. School records for TDs (92), passing yards (11,402) who is accurate short, midrange or deep. Downside: level of competition, always lined up in shotgun.

10. Aaron Murray

Georgia, 6-01⁄2, 207

Nice delivery; set SEC records for passing yards (13,166) and TD passes (121). Mobility to keep plays going. But he's mistake-prone when under heavy pressure, which suggests he could struggle in NFL.

Best fit for Steelers

Very unlikely the Steelers will expend a pick on a QB only one year after taking Landry Jones in fourth round. But Jeff Mathews (6-31⁄2, 223) of Cornell could be attractive if he isn't drafted. He has arm strength and velocity and set 17 Ivy League passing records.

One to watch

Dustin Vaughan

West Texas A&M, 6-5, 235

Vaughan could be a late-round find in this deep QB draft. He's tall, strong-armed and threw for a Division II-leading 5,501 yards in '13, and he wasn't overwhelmed in the NFLPA Collegiate Bowl.


Tom Savage

Pitt, 6-31⁄2, 228

Savage could be only the third Pitt QB drafted as high as the second round, joining Dan Marino (first, '83) and Matt Cavanaugh (second, '78); no other QB has gone above the eighth round. Few would have predicted that before Savage's only Panthers season.

Related Stories
By Alan Robinson
Thursday, May 1, 2014, 9:57 p.m.

Is this the greatest quarterback draft class since 2004? Or a class that might get a half-dozen general managers fired within a few years?

Draft analysts Mike Mayock of NFL Network and Mel Kiper Jr. of ESPN believe there might be a dozen quarterbacks in this draft who could start in the league.

But unlike the '04 trio of Eli Manning, Philip Rivers and Ben Roethlisberger, this class led by Johnny Manziel, Blake Bortles and Teddy Bridgewater is causing as much trepidation as anticipation.

Each has a major upside — Manziel with his intangibles, Bortles with his classic QB stature, Bridgewater with his strong arm. Each seems likely to go in the first round — unlike a year ago, when EJ Manuel of Buffalo was the only QB chosen on Day 1.

But each has major risks, the kind that can sink a career.

There's such quality depth that even the fourth and fifth rounds will yield possible starters, Kiper said. But given that nine of the 14 GMs who took a QB in the first round since 2009 no longer have their jobs, the thosewho take Manziel, Bortles and Bridgewater might go to sleep that night nervous.

Alan Robinson is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. Reach him at or via Twitter @arobinson_Trib.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read NFL

  1. NFL notebook: Cowboys RB Murray breaks hand, has surgery
  2. NFL notebook: Cowboys won’t rule out RB Murray
  3. NFL notebook: Bears bench QB Cutler, turn to Clausen
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.