| Sports

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Expanded NFL replay draws mixed reviews

Steelers/NFL Videos

Email Newsletters

Sign up for one of our email newsletters.
Jeff Fisher, Rams coach and member of the NFL competition committee, answers questions about rule changes during a news conference at the NFL's annual owners meeting Wednesday, March 26, 2014, in Orlando, Fla.

In an instance

How the four major North American pro sports leagues handle replays:

NFL: Shifts to centralized review in 2014; referees will make the final call after consulting with league office in New York. Teams get two challenges per game; a third is awarded if the first two are successful. Not all calls can be challenged; those that can be mostly involve possession and the spotting of the ball. Replay first started in 1986.

MLB: Centralized replay begins Monday. Three major league umpires will work at the Replay Operations Center in New York each day to make rulings. Managers get one challenge per game; if successful, they receive a second. Any home run or home plate collision can be reviewed at the discretion of the crew chief. Replay started in 2008 but only for boundary calls, such as balls hit near the tops of walls or the foul poles. Now, force plays, tag plays, fair-foul calls in the outfield and hit batters, among others, can be reviewed.

NHL: Replay started in 1991. Determines only if goals are within the rules. All calls are made in NHL Situation Room in Toronto. No coaches' challenges.

NBA: Replay started in 2002. Calls currently made by game officials after reviewing plays on video monitors located at the scorer's table. Fourteen calls can be reviewed, including whether shots were taken or fouls were committed before the end of a quarter, and whether a shot was a 2-point or 3-point basket. Centralized replay to be adopted for 2014-15 season.

By Alan Robinson
Saturday, March 29, 2014, 10:48 p.m.

Antonio Brown stretches high for a Ben Roethlisberger pass thrown near the Ravens sidelines. Climbing higher for the ball than a 5-foot-10 receiver should, Brown cradles it in his hands, only to lose possession as cornerback Lardarius Webb yanks hard on his jersey.

Only there's no penalty — the field judge is a bit late getting downfield and is screened from the obvious pass interference as Brown and Webb collide. No other official moves in to throw a flag.

Mike Tomlin and Todd Haley start yelling on the Steelers bench. Backup quarterback Bruce Gradkowski tosses his headset in disgust. The millions of fans watching on TV realize it's a penalty, and so do most of the 65,500 inside Heinz Field.

Obviously, the replay team watching at the NFL's new Central Command center in New York will correct this egregious error, right?

Uh, no.

The centralized replay system adopted by NFL owners last week in Orlando, Fla., is designed to speed up reviews, improve accuracy and correct some blown calls — like the touchdown referee Jeff Triplette mistakenly awarded the Bengals last season when BenJarvus Green-Ellis was tripped up before crossing the goal line.

But while having the league office overseeing replay represents the most dramatic change to the process since the NFL became the first major pro sports league to adopt a replay system in 1986, not every wrong will be made right.

The replay system is expanding, but what can be reviewed will stay the same, except that control of a loose ball is subject to review. But centralized replay can't retroactively assess a holding penalty, a roughing the passer call or correct an inadvertent whistle.

Rams coach Jeff Fisher, a member of the league's influential competition committee, said the NFL will constantly analyze the replay process in an effort to make it better. But he also said less than 50 percent of the coaches agreed with Patriots coach Bill Belichick and Ravens coach John Harbaugh that any play should be reviewable.

“With technology changing, the fact that the membership agreed to allow Dean Blandino (the NFL vice president of officiating) and his group to oversee and consult with officials is a major step,” Fisher said. “We are constantly evaluating our replay system because we all want to get things right.”

It's a step forward to Harbaugh but not enough of one because, he said, “When the fans have a better view of the game (on TV) than the referee does, it's time to put the referee in the same playing field as the fans.”

So how will the new, albeit not all-encompassing, replay system work?

NFL clubs were told that as soon as a referee announces a challenge, he will talk with Blandino or senior director of officiating Alberto Riveron, who will begin the review in New York even before the referee goes under the replay hood. The replay official in the press box will be consulted as to which TV angles should be shown to the referee.

Because New York can start looking at a play almost immediately, the league believes it will speed up the replay process.

While the NFL insists the referee will make the final call, some coaches, general managers and owners are skeptical because they believe most, if not all, calls will be decided by New York.

Referees, they believe, will not want to go against their bosses.

The NFL's adoption of centralized replay, and the NBA's plan to do so by next season, means that the four major pro sports leagues all will have such systems by next year.

No doubt the NFL was motivated to improve its system following several major officiating missteps last season — and not just the one in which Tomlin wasn't penalized for impeding kick returner Jacoby Jones in Baltimore, only to be fined $100,000 by the league a few days later.

There also was an improperly moved first-down marker during the Giants-Redskins game, an incorrect play clock reset in Eagles-Cowboys and, of course, an uncalled illegal formation against the Chargers on a final-week Chiefs field goal attempt that, if successful, would have sent the Steelers to the playoffs.

For those fans who say an extra official would help, the league is weighing whether to experiment with eight-man crews during the preseason, according to the NFL Network.

Tomlin said officials don't get enough credit for doing a remarkably hard job exceptionally well — most of the time. It's those other times that trouble coaches, players and fans alike.

“I think it (centralized replay) is a good idea because the bottom line is we want to get it right,” Carolina Panthers coach Ron Rivera said. “The more people that look at plays that are being reviewed, the better chance of getting it right.”

Alan Robinson is a staff writer for Trib Total Media. Reach him at or via Twitter @arobinson_Trib.

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Steelers

  1. Steelers’ Roethlisberger remains in concussion protocol
  2. Starkey: Tomlin lived in his fears
  3. Steelers receiver Wheaton takes advantage of opportunity in breakout game
  4. Film session: Long shots dotted Steelers’ passing game
  5. Steelers notebook: Bryant confident in backup Jones if Big Ben can’t play
  6. Steelers notebook: Seahawks’ Sherman gets better of WR Brown
  7. Steelers players say they support Tomlin’s attempts at deception
  8. Week 12 — Steelers-Seahawks gameday grades
  9. Steelers stalled by Seahawks, on outside of AFC wild-card picture
  10. Steelers’ Roethlisberger reported symptoms that led to his exit vs. Seahawks
  11. Steelers plan to use smart pass rush against Seattle QB Wilson