Houseboat is home, not vessel, justices rule
WASHINGTON — A house that sits on the water is a floating home, not a vessel, the Supreme Court ruled on Tuesday.
The 7-2 decision upholds laws in California, Washington and other states that say houseboats are governed by local laws applying to homes, not maritime law that regulates vessels.
Justice Stephen Breyer said a vessel is something that is “actually used for transportation.” It is not “anything that floats,” he added.
The high court ruling is a victory for a Florida man who parked his gray, two-story houseboat at a marina in Rivera Beach, Fla. City officials later seized it for unpaid fees and had it destroyed. Their decision was upheld under federal maritime law.
The owner, Fane Lozman, appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that his home would have been protected from seizure under ordinary laws governing real estate.
The justices agreed and sent the case back to Florida, where Lozman can seek to recover a $25,000 bond that was set aside.
It is not clear what the ruling will mean for riverboat casinos, an issue the court did not discuss.
Joining Breyer's opinion were Chief Justice John Roberts, and Associate Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Samuel Alito and Elena Kagan.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justice Anthony Kennedy, dissented, in the term's first dissenting votes from a full court opinion. Sotomayor objected to the “reasonable observer” standard adopted by the majority.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- 7 shot at Florida spring-break house party
- Global warming is slowing down the circulation of the oceans — with potentially dire consequences
- A bipartisan push on toxic chemicals makes some Democrats fume
- Run from Cuba, Americans cling to claims for seized property
- Bulk calling data won’t be collected
- Attorneys: Sterilizations were part of plea deal talks
- $140M Picasso likely to set auction record
- Republican presidential hopefuls near-unanimity on the issue of their own guns
- Police find no evidence in 5-month investigation of UVA rape allegations
- American crash victims: U.S. government contractor, daughter
- Keep Gitmo prisoners swapped for Bergdahl out of fight, senator says