Cuts would make using troops 'immoral,' Senate told
WASHINGTON — Pending automatic spending cuts have put the armed forces on a path to being so unprepared for combat that it would be “immoral” to use them, the Defense Department's top leaders told lawmakers on Tuesday in their most dire warning yet of how looming budget reductions could undercut military readiness.
Gen. Martin Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said in response to a question during a Senate Armed Services Committee hearing that neither he nor any of the four-star officers in charge of the military services have considered resigning to protest the billions in dollars in cuts that will begin on March 1 unless Congress acts to stop them.
“But I will tell you personally, if ever the force is so degraded and so unready, and then we're asked to use it, it would be immoral to use the force unless it's well-trained, well-led and well-equipped,” Dempsey said.
“Are we on the path to creating that dilemma?” asked Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C.
“We are on that path,” Dempsey said.
The uniformed leaders of the Army, Navy, Air Force and Marine Corps agreed with Dempsey's assessment.
The potential for the automatic cuts, called a sequester, to kick in on March 1 is the result of Congress' failure to trim the deficit by $1.2 trillion over a decade. The Pentagon faces a $46 billion budget reduction in the seven months starting in March and ending in September, and additional cuts would come in later years as long as the sequester remains in effect. The automatic cuts would be in addition to a $487 billion reduction in Defense spending over the next 10 years mandated by the Budget Control Act passed in 2011.
Further complicating the military's fiscal picture is the lack of a budget for this fiscal year. Congress hasn't approved one. Lawmakers have instead been passing bills called continuing resolutions, which keep spending levels at the same rate as the year before. That means the Pentagon is operating on less money than planned, and that compounds the problem, Defense officials said. A freeze on hiring is in place, and the military has cut back on maintenance at bases and facilities, they said.
Defense Secretary Leon Panetta said last week that the United States is at risk of becoming a second-rate military power if the sequester isn't prevented. If the reductions are allowed to stand, Panetta said he would have to throw the country's national defense strategy “out the window.”
Dempsey, the service chiefs and Deputy Defense Secretary Ashton Carter added greater detail during the hearing.
Dempsey said “military readiness is in jeopardy due to the convergence of unprecedented budget factors.” If the situation isn't fixed, he said, the armed forces “will have much less of everything and therefore be able to provide fewer options to our nation's leaders.”
Sen. Kelly Ayotte, R-N.H., asked Dempsey to rate the dangers of sequestration on a scale of one to 10, with 10 being the most severe.
“From where I sit today, it sure feels like a 10,” Dempsey said. None of the other witnesses disagreed.
Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., described the military's financial situation as “kind of an Orwellian experience” because it's occurring when North Korea has tested a nuclear weapon, Iran remains a threat in the Persian Gulf region, and Iraq, Libya, Egypt, Mali and Tunisia all are in a state of unrest.
“We are probably in a more unsettled period since the end of the Cold War that certainly I have ever seen,” McCain said. No one at the witness table disputed McCain's assessment.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- States ask judge not to lift stay in immigration lawsuit
- Expanded background checks pushed again on gun show, Internet purchases
- Oil spill in Washington river endangers wildlife
- Tribune-Review poll: Cable news rises as network news falls
- GOP admits defeat as Congress approves Homeland funding
- Feds raid ‘maternity hotels’ in Ca.
- FDA orders warning on testosterone pills
- 8 shot to death, including gunman, in Missouri rampage
- Lawmakers press Veterans Affairs for improved access to rural health care
- More Indian tribes rethink idea of legalized marijuana on reservations
- Suspects’ search of victims’ homes OK’d in Colorado