| USWorld

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Senate Dems' budget extends fight with GOP

Email Newsletters

Click here to sign up for one of our email newsletters.

Competing proposals

How the budget plans by Senate Democrats and House Republicans would stack up over the next decade:

Total spending

Democrats: $46.5 trillion

Republicans: $41.7 trillion

Total revenue

Democrats: $41.2 trillion

Republicans: $40.2 trillion

10-year deficit

Democrats: $5.4 trillion

Republicans: $1.4 trillion

National debt at end of 2023

Democrats: $24.4 trillion

Republicans: $20.3 trillion

Social Security

Democrats: $11.3 trillion

Republicans: $11.3 trillion


Democrats: $6.8 trillion

Republicans: $6.7 trillion

Health (including Medicaid and the State Children's Health Insurance Program)

Democrats: $6.6 trillion

Republicans: $4.0 trillion

National defense

Democrats: $6.0 trillion

Republicans: $6.2 trillion

Income security (including housing assistance, cash benefits and food stamps)

Democrats: $5.6 trillion

Republicans: $5.0 trillion

Interest on national debt

Democrats: $5.2 trillion

Republicans: $4.5 trillion

Veterans benefits and services

Democrats: $1.7 trillion

Republicans: $1.7 trillion

International affairs (including foreign aid)

Democrats: $506 billion

Republicans: $431 billion

Education, training, employment and social services

Democrats: $1.1 trillion

Republicans: $906 billion


Democrats: $919 billion

Republicans: $801 billion


Democrats: $205 billion

Republicans: $196 billion

Natural resources and environment

Democrats: $474 billion

Republicans: $385 billion

Community and regional development

Democrats: $268 billion

Republicans: $88 billion

Daily Photo Galleries

By The Associated Press
Saturday, March 23, 2013, 8:27 p.m.

WASHINGTON — An exhausted Senate gave pre-dawn approval on Saturday to a Democratic $3.7 trillion budget for next year that embraces nearly $1 trillion in tax increases during the coming decade but shelters domestic programs targeted for cuts by House Republicans.

With their victory by a razor-thin 50-49 vote, the budget allows Democrats to tout their priorities. Yet it fails to resolve the deep differences between the two parties over deficits and the size of government.

Joining all Republicans voting “no” were four Democrats who face re-election next year in potentially difficult races: Sens. Max Baucus of Montana, Mark Begich of Alaska, Kay Hagan of North Carolina and Mark Pryor of Arkansas. Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., did not vote.

White House spokesman Jay Carney praised the Senate plan, saying in a statement it “will create jobs and cut the deficit in a balanced way.”

While calling on both sides to find common ground, Carney did not hold out much hope for compromise with Republicans. The rival budget passed by the GOP-led House cuts social programs too deeply, he said, and fails “to ask for a single dime of deficit reduction from closing tax loopholes for the wealthy and well-connected.”

The Senate vote came after lawmakers labored through the night on scores of symbolic amendments, ranging from voicing support for letting states collect taxes on Internet sales to expressing opposition to requiring photo IDs for voters.

Final approval came about 5 a.m., capping 20 hours of votes and debate. As the night wore on, virtually all senators remained in the chamber — a rarity during a normal business day.

The Senate's budget plan would shrink annual federal shortfalls over the next decade to nearly $400 billion, raise unspecified taxes by $975 billion and cull modest savings from domestic programs.

In contrast, a rival budget plan approved by the GOP-run House balances the budget within 10 years without boosting taxes.

That blueprint — by House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, R-Wis., his party's vice presidential candidate last year — claims $4 trillion more in savings over the period than Senate Democrats by digging deeply into Medicaid, food stamps and other safety-net programs for the needy. It also would transform the Medicare health care program for seniors into a voucher-like system for future recipients.

“We have presented very different visions for how our country should work and who it should work for,” said Senate Budget Committee Chairman Patty Murray, D-Wash.

The long Senate debate got testy at times.

As the clock ticked past 1 a.m., Murray asked senators to show respect for colleagues “who may not be able to stand as long as us, or who are elderly.”

Sen. David Vitter, R-La., shot back that Republicans were not trying to delay anything, and he wondered what flights or appointments would be missed if senators voted until 7 a.m.

The loudest acclaim occurred toward the end, when senators rose as one to cheer a handful of Senate pages — high school students — for their work in the chamber since the morning's opening gavel. Senators then left town for a two-week spring recess.

Congressional budgets are planning documents that leave actual changes in revenues and spending for later legislation, and this was the first the Democratic-run Senate has approved in four years.

That lapse is testament to the political and mathematical contortions needed to write fiscal plans in an era of record-breaking deficits, and to the parties' profoundly conflicting views.

“I believe we're in denial about the financial condition of our country,” said Sen. Jeff Sessions, R-Ala., a budget panelist.

Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Nation

  1. Coal industry seeks unusual partner in UN green climate fund
  2. Alaska to feel remnants of former Hurricane Oho
  3. Civil servants’ pay, benefits exceed private-sector counterparts, Cato study finds
  4. Wrong drug may have been used in Okla. execution
  5. Oregon college town sets gun rights protest for Obama visit
  6. Ex-CEO of Chicago Public Schools to plead guilty to $23 million kickback scheme
  7. McCarthy withdraws candidacy for speaker
  8. McCarthy drops out as GOP speaker candidate in shocker
  9. Raids aim to weed out growers on federal land
  10. Ohio teacher accused in husband’s vehicular death gets job back
  11. SeaWorld’s expansion of orca tanks criticized