Therapy to turn gay teens straight: Free speech or treatment? California court wrestles with law seeking ban
SAN FRANCISCO — California's novel law seeking to ban licensed counselors from trying to turn gay teens straight is boiling down to a question over whether the therapy is free speech or a medical treatment that can be regulated by government.
It's the “pivot point” of the legal debate, Judge Morgan Christen of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said on Wednesday.
Morgan and two other judges on the nation's largest federal appellate court considered 90 minutes of legal arguments over the ban on “sexual-orientation change” counseling of minors, which other states are considering.
The three-judge panel is considering two challenges to the law approved in California last fall. It took no action on Wednesday and will issue a written ruling later.
The law was to go into effect Jan. 1, but the court put it on hold pending its decision.
Chief Judge Alex Kozinski noted the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a California ban of violent video games because the state failed to show a compelling reason to infringe on game-makers' free-speech rights to manufacture the products.
He said it appeared the same argument could be applied to the evidence lawmakers relied on in passing the prohibition on sexual-orientation change therapy.
“We really don't have anything compelling, as I see it,” Kozinski said. “Government has to have a compelling interest in curtailing speech.”
California Deputy Attorney General Alexandra Robert Gordon, who is defending the ban, cited mainstream medical organizations' support of the law, and testimony before the state Legislature by several people who said they were harmed by the counseling.
Kozinski replied that opponents of the law also testified before lawmakers that they benefited from the counseling.
“There is evidence going both ways,” Kozinski concluded.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Less sleep increases your chance of catching a cold, researchers say
- Lost hiker survived 9 days with broken leg in California’s Sierra Nevada
- Supreme Court rules against Kentucky county clerk on gay marriage licenses
- Russia, China ply cyberdata to exploit U.S. spies
- Suspect in Houston-area deputy’s death has history of mental illness, prosecutors say
- Postal Service falls short of slower mail delivery standards
- McKinley backers balk over mountain’s name change
- CDC lauds schools for better nutrition
- Federal Reserve Vice Chairman Fischer open to interest rate hike
- Alaska-bound, Obama makes waves by renaming Mount McKinley
- Clinton: Women ‘expect’ extremism from terrorists, not GOP candidates