Terrorism case gets new twist
By The Associated Press
Published: Tuesday, Sept. 3, 2013, 10:00 p.m.
CHICAGO — A federal judge in a Chicago terrorism case has undone a key ruling in which she found the government need not divulge whether its investigation relied on expanded phone and Internet surveillance programs — opening the sensitive issue back up to debate.
U.S. District Judge Sharon Johnson Coleman took the rare step over the weekend of vacating that initial finding days after siding with government attorneys prosecuting Adel Daoud, a 19-year-old citizen accused of trying to ignite what he thought was a bomb next to a downtown Chicago bar last year.
Former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden leaked documents revealing the scope of surveillance programs earlier this year.
If they learn the government did use enhanced surveillance to trigger its investigation of Daoud, defense lawyers have said they would challenge subsequent evidence on grounds it violated protections against unreasonable searches.
Coleman last week seemed to dash defense hopes of mounting such a constitutional challenge when she accepted prosecutors' argument that — because they don't intend to use evidence derived directly from expanded surveillance at Daoud's trial — they aren't required to disclose if they relied on the programs.
In a brief docket entry Sunday, however, Coleman granted a defense motion that she vacate her earlier ruling. The judge wrote that she found “no prejudice in allowing further examination of this issue.”
Both defense attorneys and a prosecutors' spokesman declined comment Tuesday.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Shale oil, gas drilling boom wins favor with labor unions, thwarting environmentalists
- Teen OK after riding in wheel well of Hawaii jet
- After bombs, Boston Marathon under tight security
- Postal Service overhaul expected to appeal to Dems
- Subsitute for Pap smear scorned; overtreatment cited
- Art from ‘Dick and Jane’ series set for auction
- Study of corn waste as fuel source finds gasoline less damaging to atmosphere
- Ruling on Cleveland police chase questioned
- Navy endorses 24-hour sleep cycle for sailors
- Mauling puts bears back on firing line in Central Florida
- Warnings on youths, codeine unheeded; lack of effectiveness, dangers had been raised