Dual-leadership role at NSA and Cyber Command stirs debate
WASHINGTON — During suspected Iranian cyberattacks on the websites of commercial banks last year, Gen. Keith Alexander, who simultaneously heads the country's largest electronic spy agency and the military's Cyber Command, proposed a simple solution: Shut off the attacks at their source.
“We had the expertise and could have done something about it,” said one official, speaking on the condition of anonymity to describe sensitive discussions. “We're sitting on their networks overseas. Why don't we just turn it off?”
But the proposal to send a simple computer “reset” command to the attacking servers was ultimately rejected by National Security Council officials this year because the attacks were not causing enough harm to warrant an offensive response.
The episode shows the willingness — some say eagerness — of Alexander to use his authority to conduct offensive actions to fend off attacks against the private sector.
As he builds out Cyber Command at Fort Meade. Md., and other installations to a fighting force of 6,000 over the next three years, there are fresh questions about the wisdom of so much power residing in one “dual-hatted” official.
“The mashing together of the NSA and Cyber Command has blurred the lines between a military command and a national spy agency,” said Peter Singer, a Brookings Institution expert on evolving modes of warfare.
Alexander disagrees. “It's one network,” he said recently. “We all operate on the same network. You create more problems by trying to separate them and have two people fighting over who's in charge (of both missions) than putting it all together. I think our nation benefits from that.”
He said that other countries “do similar things.”
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- White House breach ‘a cry out for help,’ alleged intruder’s ex-wife says
- Legislators urge Secret Service to reassess White House security
- Militia leader jailed in Army ID theft
- 121 tourists stranded on schooner near Statue of Liberty
- Beads in beauty products called toxin
- FBI, federal marshals join manhunt for survivalist accused of ambushing troopers
- 32 structures destroyed in California’s King wildfire
- Scope of Chrysler’s latest SUV recall questioned
- Ticks reduce moose population in northern states
- U.S. confident it’ll have allies for airstrikes against ISIS
- Mentally ill Pa. man might go free in 9/11 scare