Supreme Court to debate mental disability in Fla. death penalty case
WASHINGTON — Freddie Lee Hall has survived Florida's death row for decades since he was convicted and sentenced for a 1978 murder.
Now the Supreme Court will use his case to judge the state's strict standard for determining when a convicted criminal's mental disability is severe enough to rule out the death penalty.
On Monday, the high court announced that it will hear Hall's challenge to Florida's rule that a convicted criminal must have a tested IQ of 69 or lower in order to be deemed intellectually disabled. This determination is a matter of life or death, as the Supreme Court has ruled previously that the intellectually disabled — formerly referred to as the mentally retarded — cannot face the death penalty.
“I'm very pleased they will be taking the case up,” said Eric Pinkard, Hall's Tampa-based appellate attorney. “The Florida definition leads to the possibility that the mentally retarded will be executed.”
Whitney Ray, the press secretary to Florida Attorney General Pamela Jo Bondi, said in a statement that Florida courts had found that Hall “is not intellectually disabled. We will urge the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold Hall's sentence.”
Pinkard argues that Florida's explicit definition, which allows the execution of someone with a tested IQ of 70 or above, fails to account for standard measurement error. The Supreme Court itself, in the 2002 decision protecting the intellectually disabled from execution, declared that an IQ between 70 and 75 is typically considered the cutoff score.
The sixteenth of 17 children, Hall was “tortured by his mother and abused by his neighbors,” according to a 1993 dissenting opinion in the Florida Supreme Court. He had an IQ of 60 and was “functionally illiterate and has the short-term memory of a first-grader,” the dissenting opinion observed. In later years, though, Hall's IQ was variously measured at 71 and 73.
Hall and Mack Ruffin Jr. were charged in the Feb. 21, 1978, murders of Karol Lea Hurst, a 21-year-old housewife who was seven months pregnant, and Hernando County Deputy Sheriff Lonnie Coburn. According to a court summary, Hall and Ruffin collaborated in kidnapping Hurst in her own car from a Pantry Pride supermarket parking lot in Leesburg, Fla. They drove to a wooded area, where, Hall told investigators, Ruffin beat, sexually assaulted and shot Hurst.
Shortly thereafter, prosecutors say, Coburn confronted the men and was killed with his own gun.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Glenn Beck takes on Common Core
- Death penalty foes decry bungled execution
- Biden pushes economic plan
- Obama wants to end U.S. companies skirting tax laws by merging with overseas entities
- Russia firing into Ukraine, U.S. intel finds
- Psychiatrist returns fire in hospital shooting; caseworker killed in gunplay
- Poverty programs would be merged
- White House, senators close on bill to end NSA spying
- Scientists: Earth in midst of 6th ‘mass extinction’
- After 40 years, Wyo. fossil trove to get another look
- Tyrannosaurs ran in packs, fossils prove