1st 9/11-related trial in U.S. unfolds
WASHINGTON — Weeks after he took office, President Obama met privately with 40 grieving Americans, many clutching photographs of loved ones lost in terrorist attacks.
The president told them that he would close the Guantanamo Bay military prison within the year and put many of the detainees there on trial in the United States, where justice would be swifter.
Five years later, the first and probably only federal court trial of a Sept. 11-related case will start with jury selection on Monday in a U.S. District courthouse in lower Manhattan, not far from where the World Trade Center stood.
In addition to being the first opportunity for Obama to fulfill that 2009 pledge, it will likely be the only chance for New Yorkers, the community most damaged in the worst terror attack in U.S. history, to have such a trial on their home turf, decided by a jury of New Yorkers.
Obama's plans to relocate other Guantanamo detainees, most notably confessed Sept. 11 mastermind Khalid Shaikh Mohammed and four others accused in the plot, ran into congressional roadblocks that prevented the president from trying them in New York and closing the Cuba detention facility as he promised.
But when Sulaiman abu Ghaith, 48, Osama bin Laden's son-in-law, who is accused of being a top al-Qaida propagandist, was arrested last year, the Justice Department brushed aside pressure to send him to Guantanamo and began proceedings in New York, partly as a test case to demonstrate that high-profile terrorism trials could be handled safely and efficiently in the United States.
Abu Ghaith's trial has moved far faster than in the military process at Guantanamo Bay, where only a handful of tribunals have been completed. Half of the remaining 150 detainees have been cleared for release yet remain locked up, and the other half are being held indefinitely as enemy combatants. Mohammed and his fellow defendants have been in custody for 11 years with no trial in sight.
Federal prosecutors in New York are hoping to prove that justice can move faster there. They are seeking life in prison with no parole for abu Ghaith, who is accused of being an al-Qaida leader and calling for more attacks after Sept. 11. Prosecutors did not seek the death penalty because abu Ghaith is not accused of directly planning or carrying out acts of terrorism.
According to the government, soon after the twin towers fell, abu Ghaith began encouraging Muslims to battle the United States
“Jihad is a duty,” he proclaimed. “Americans must know that the storm of airplanes will not stop, God willing, and there are thousands of young people who are as keen about death as Americans are about life.”
Retired New York Deputy fire Chief Jim Riches, whose son, firefighter Jimmy Riches, died at the World Trade Center, said he is eager to attend the abu Ghaith trial in New York.
“This is where they committed the crime,” said Riches, who has attended hearings at Guantanamo Bay and criticized those tribunals for their frustratingly slow pace. “We'll get justice here. I'll be dead before there's a trial down there.”
But despite the president's assurance that the federal court system is a better place to administer justice, many relatives — and politicians — question whether terrorism suspects should be prosecuted in the United States. Some have said foreign terrorism suspects should not benefit from the same legal due-process rights afforded American citizens. They worry detainees will exploit the court system and use trials as public platforms to spread their ideology. They say those accused of war crimes belong in the military legal system at Guantanamo Bay, safely away from American. shores.
“I just don't like the thought they would even be allowed to be here, where they hurt so many people,” said Rosaleen Tallon, another parent of a firefighter lost on 9/11, Sean Patrick Tallon.
For the Justice Department, much is riding on the trial and verdict in abu Ghaith's case. Anything short of a life sentence could be seen as a failure.
Show commenting policy
TribLive commenting policy
- Obama hopes he has enough votes to sustain a potential veto of Iran nuke deal; pro-Israel groups aim to stop it
- Defense memo reveals plan to protect transgender troops
- Cruz switches targets, takes exception with IRS practices
- Cincy officer indicted on murder charge in fatal shooting of motorist
- Mich. high court strikes down mandatory fees for state employees in unions
- New TSA administrator vows training to address security gaps
- Feds accuse Philadelphia congressman Fattah of corruption
- Calif. oil slick expected to dissipate
- Recessions convince students to switch majors, leading to more business, engineering majors, researchers find
- Compromise keeps highway accounts funded
- Oklahoma earthquakes shut down wells