TribLIVE

| USWorld


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Tests said to prove claim of earlier 'Mona Lisa' version

REUTERS
Professor Alessandro Vezzosi, director of the Museo Ideale Leonardo da Vinci, points to details on a painting attributed to Leonardo da Vinci and depicting Mona Lisa during a presentation in Geneva in September 27, 2012. New tests on the painting billed as the original version of the Mona Lisa, Leonardo da Vinci's iconic 15th century portrait, have produced fresh proof that it is the work of the Italian master, the Swiss-based Mona Lisa Foundation said on February 13, 2013.

Daily Photo Galleries

By Reuters
Friday, Feb. 15, 2013, 12:01 a.m.
 

GENEVA — New tests on a painting billed as the original version of the Mona Lisa, Leonardo da Vinci's 15th century portrait, have produced fresh proof that it is the work of the Italian master, a Swiss-based art foundation said.

The tests, one by a specialist in “sacred geometry” and the other by the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, were carried out in the wake of the Geneva unveiling of the painting, the “Isleworth Mona Lisa,” last September.

“When we add these new findings to the wealth of scientific and physical studies we already had, I believe anyone will find the evidence of a Leonardo attribution overwhelming,” said David Feldman, vice-president of the foundation.

The “Mona Lisa” in the Paris Louvre for over three centuries has long been regarded as the only one painted by Leonardo — although there have been copies — and claims for the Swiss-held one were dismissed by some experts last year.

But it also won support in the art world, encouraging the Zurich-based Mona Lisa Foundation — an international group which says it has no financial interest in the work — to pursue efforts to demonstrate its authenticity.

Feldman, an Irish-born international art and stamp dealer, said he was contacted after the public unveiling of the portrait — which shows a much younger woman than in the Louvre — by Italian geometrist Alfonso Rubino.

“He has made extended studies of the geometry of Leonardo's Vitruvian Man” — a sketch of a youth with arms and legs extended — “and offered to look at our painting to see if it conformed,” Feldman said.

The conclusion by the Padua-based Rubino was that the “Isleworth” portrait — named for a London suburb where it was kept by British art connoisseur Hugh Blaker 80-90 years ago — matched Leonardo's geometry and must be his.

The Zurich institute, the Foundation said, carried out a carbon-dating test on the canvas of its painting and found that it was almost certainly manufactured between 1410 and 1455 — refuting claims that it was a late 16th century copy.

Earlier brush-stroke studies presented last September by U.S. physicist and art lover John Asmus concluded that the “original” version and the Louvre crowd-puller were painted by the same artist.

The authenticity of the foundation's painting, discovered by Blaker in an English country house in 1913, has been fiercely challenged by British Leonardo authority Martin Kemp, who argued last year that “so much is wrong with it.”

Feldman and foundation colleagues retort that Kemp has never followed up on invitations to come to see it.

Documents show that a painting of his wife Lisa was commissioned around the turn of the 16th century by Florentine nobleman Francesco del Giacondo. In French, the Louvre version is known as “La Giaconde” and “La Giaconda” in Italian.

Supporters of the “younger” version say it was almost certainly delivered unfinished to del Giacondo before Leonardo left Italy in 1506 and took up residence in France, where he died in 1519 in a small Loire chateau.

From the Giacondo house, it probably eventually found its way to England after being bought by a travelling English aristocrat, this account runs, while the Paris version was probably painted by Leonardo around 1516 in France.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read World

  1. Kurdish Iraqi forces battle ISIS to try to clear way to Syrian border
  2. Russia acts to stanch ruble’s plummet
  3. Bad day for Israel: U.N. criticizes West Bank settlements; Hamas off EU terror list
  4. Russia acts to stanch plummet of ruble’s value
  5. Grief in Pakistan over school rampage turns to anger toward military
  6. Female bishop a first for Church of England
  7. Taliban siege at Pakistani school ends with 141 dead
  8. Hope for better days in Pakistan shattered in school attack
  9. Islamic State terrorists shoot down Iraqi military helicopter
  10. Russia says it has right to put nukes in Crimea
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.