TribLIVE

| Home


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

West Penn Allegheny seeks judge's removal from lawsuit

Daily Photo Galleries

Tuesday, March 13, 2012
 

Picking up a gauntlet thrown down by a federal judge, West Penn Allegheny Health System has asked a higher court to remove the judge from the antitrust lawsuit it filed against UPMC.

U.S. District Judge Arthur Schwab issued the challenged in February when he halted the case after West Penn suggested in a footnote to a motion that some of the judge's recent decisions had the appearance of bias in favor of UPMC.

The judge told West Penn that the footnote was effectively a motion seeking his removal from the case. He then "denied that ‘motion' and indefinitely stayed the litigation pending review by this court," West Penn says in its March 2 appeal to the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.

Schwab's "actions go well beyond managing the judicial process and ruling on issues raised by the litigants," West Penn said in the appeal. "Instead, the district court independently has raised and addressed issues never placed before it by a party."

West Penn claims in the lawsuit that UPMC has engaged in monopolistic practices to drive it out of business. The lawsuit originally claimed that Highmark Inc. had conspired with UPMC in the monopolistic practices, but West Penn dropped Highmark from the lawsuit after the insurer agreed to buy West Penn for $475 million.

In addition to asking the appeals court to remove Schwab from the case, West Penn is asking the justices to reverse Schwab's Feb. 1 order that the health system has to turn over information about its business operations to UPMC before the judge rules on whether West Penn can file a new complaint that names only UPMC as a defendant.

Schwab and a UPMC spokesman couldn't immediately be reached for comment.

 

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Starkey: Hockey hypocrites, unite
  2. Prime time not kind to Heinz Field
  3. State police trooper seriously hurt when hit by vehicle in East Huntingdon
  4. Steelers offense puts up gaudy numbers in season’s 1st half
  5. Lifesharing allows families to open homes, hearts to disabled
  6. Steelers notebook: Roethlisberger, offense must adjust with CB Smith out
  7. Penguins veteran defenseman Scuderi’s game looking up
  8. Range Resources reports $146M in Q3 profits on record Marcellus production
  9. Ferrante murder trial heads into day 6 with testimony on cyanide, Web searches
  10. Kiski Valley-based ring charged with hundreds of thefts over 10 communities
  11. Gorman: For Bethel Park, the worst road trip in WPIAL playoffs
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.