TribLIVE

| News


 
Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Cleared St. Vincent priest sues, alleges defamation

Daily Photo Galleries

Westmoreland Photo Galleries

By Richard Gazarik
Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2010
 

The attorney for a suspended priest at St. Vincent College and Archabbey in a defamation action charged that the bishop of the Greensburg Catholic Diocese based his decision on "erroneous allegations and defamatory information" supplied by college officials.

The Rev. Mark Gruber, who is a Benedictine monk and anthropology professor, was suspended from teaching last year by Archabbott Douglas Nowicki. Bishop Lawrence Brandt suspended Gruber's priestly functions after Nowicki and other St. Vincent officials told the bishop that Gruber had downloaded child pornography on a college computer, according to a lawsuit.

Though Gruber is a member of the Benedictine Order, Brandt has authority over all priests within the diocese.

A state police investigation cleared Gruber of any criminality, but the school refused to reinstate him even after a student came forward and admitted that he downloaded some of the material onto a computer used by Gruber, according to the suit.

In addition to Nowicki and Brandt, Gruber has sued former St. Vincent president H. James Towey and several other school officials in Westmoreland County court for accusing Gruber of being a "sexual predator, child molester, deviant ... despite the fact they should have known that those statements were false," wrote attorney Sharon Smith of Mt. Lebanon, who represents Gruber.

The actions by Nowicki and the other defendants placed a "horrific label" on Gruber and forced him to undergo psychiatric treatment, according to the filing.

"The actions of the bishop and diocese ... were grounded in the defamatory information supplied by the St. Vincent defendants," she wrote.

Gruber, who has written several books on anthropology and religion, was a critic of Towey during his tenure as president. He criticized Towey in interviews to national academic publications and served as faculty spokesman in complaining about Towey to the school's board of trustees.

According to the suit, the college was motivated to retaliate against Gruber, who was suspected of authoring an essay that was critical of Towey and falsely contained the signature of another monk.

The investigation was triggered when Eddie Dejthai, director of information technology at St. Vincent, checked the hard drive on Gruber's computer and found pictures of naked males. Dejthai is the son-in-law of Dennis Grace, who was Towey's chief of staff and now is a vice president at the college.

Investigators concluded that the photos were of men older than 18 and said no crime had been committed. District Attorney John Peck, after reviewing the findings, declined to prosecute Gruber.

Towey left St. Vincent in May and was replaced as president by Brother Norman Hipps.

 

 
 


Show commenting policy

Most-Read Westmoreland

  1. Fire damages silo on Salem farm
  2. Harrison City-Export Road opening delayed
  3. Emaciated Lab-collie mix found in garbage bag in New Stanton
  4. New Indian Creed Valley Trail segment, bridge dedication set
  5. Convicted killer won’t be freed in 1973 double-murder of children
  6. Smithfield woman faces probation in insurance company theft
  7. MAX Environmental fined for ordinance violations
  8. Friends take to social media to recall Herminie teen
  9. Trust for Hempfield cemetery low on cash; bank asks to be absolved of responsibility
  10. Wanted: Youngwood Borough Council member
  11. Razing of Monsour Medical Center in Jeannette within reach with $1M grant
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.