| News

Larger text Larger text Smaller text Smaller text | Order Photo Reprints

Privacy rights a concern with surveillance cameras

Daily Photo Galleries

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Police and prosecutors love surveillance cameras but civil libertarians call them a good thing that can be misused.

Having the cameras in public places is clearly allowed, said University of Pittsburgh law professor John Burkoff. The nation's highest courts have repeatedly approved their use.

But citizens still have privacy rights, and the courts say there are "reasonable" exceptions, he said.

"The question is: what is reasonable?"

The possibility of misuse should trouble citizens, said Sara Rose, a spokeswoman for the American Civil Liberties Union in Pittsburgh.

"Municipalities need to take into consideration that cameras can be used improperly," Rose said. "Some have the ability to zoom in through windows, for example, and focus on women. Is that right?"

Another concern, Rose said, deals with who has access to the camera footage and who gets to see it.

And, Burkoff asks, "How does someone know if a surveillance camera is being used improperly?"

Often, he said, that remains a secret until unearthed in another investigation.

Rose questions the cameras' effectiveness.

"There's not a lot of evidence of any reduction in crime," Rose said. Instead, she said the cameras simply push crime somewhere else.

There are more surveillance cameras per mile in England than anywhere else, according to Burkett.

"The good thing is, if there is a problem, there is some record of it for law enforcement," Burkett said.

"But the question is this: Do we want to live in a society like that• I don't think so."



Show commenting policy

Most-Read Stories

  1. Police: 2 anti-violence organizers beat ex-roomie in Washington
  2. Steelers notebook: Ravens enter short-handed at tight end
  3. Veteran LB Harrison: Steelers must play to way defense is set up
  4. Attorney General Kane injured in auto accident
  5. Fleury, Penguins too much for Kings
  6. ‘Big play’ moniker fits veteran Steelers cornerback Gay
  7. Foundations’ deal to buy August Wilson Center could be in jeopardy
  8. 5 Cal U football players arrested for assault; Saturday’s game canceled
  9. PA Core Standards survey link now on Connellsville district’s website
  10. Beleaguered Burkina Faso leader steps down
  11. Economy woman sentenced to 15 months for Medicare fraud
Subscribe today! Click here for our subscription offers.